Please I would like to get opinions on this breeder!

Joined
Jul 12, 2006
Messages
606
Likes
0
Points
16
Location
OH
#61
This is the line that gets me the most...

but as you know the purchasers are all humane associations who take the dogs and then re-adopt them out to others for a profit

I know there are probably come corrupt groups out there. But to actually say that ALL the purchasers are humane organizations?? WTF? Anyone who thinks rescues make a profit are highly mistaken. If you break it down in a case by case basis, some dogs might come in already fixed and perfectly healthy, get adopted fast and they still ask a $100 or whatever adoption fee. But that just makes up a little for the next dog that comes in mangled from being hit by a car needing thousands in surgery or the litter after litter of puppies that people dump off on them...

This lady is ridiculous. I HOPE HOPE HOPE the OP doesn't buy from her. I hope after hearing our advice she is smart enough to make the right decision. This is just a breeder with an answer to seemingly justify everything she does, right or wrong. Mostly wrong in this case. Seems like a very nice woman with the wrong ideals on breeding and rescue.
 

FoxyWench

Salty Sea Dog
Joined
Feb 14, 2006
Messages
7,308
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Connecticut
#62
theres just something about ALL her dogs that doesnt look right...ICKY!

and i love how she calls it an "adoption fee" its not an adoption fee, your not adopting thepet your buying it, simple...ugh!
 

adojrts

New Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
4,089
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ontario, Canada
#63
This is what she replied about health certifying her dogs, or not in this case...
I have had my dogs quite some time and alot of my adults are grandchildren and great grandchildren of my own dogs as well... If I know the history and pedigree of a certain dog I sometimes will only have the basic health testing done, if there is a questions or concern that my vet finds then I would do further testing.
My guarantee is for any health problems, not just those that I can test for etc etc...




[/I]
Oh what a bunch of BS that is, unless you test you can NOT possibly know who is effected until it is too late.
She doesn't test, she doesn't show and she is nothing but a serious BYB that just happens to have AKC reg'd dogs.......big deal. Her guarantee does not protect the dog, doesn't protect the new owner and absolutey gives her an out on many levels. BS top to bottom.
 

ihartgonzo

and Fozzie B!
Joined
May 14, 2006
Messages
5,903
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
35
Location
Northern California
#64
Run... run far, far away! D:

Any breeder who crossbreeds dogs is not worth the time of day. The fact that she mixes her dogs says A LOT about her character - she is driven, above all, to make money. Any reputable breeder would never crossbreed, especially not to feed into a stupid trend.

That is BESIDES the fact that none of her dogs are titled or health tested. And besides the fact that she has dozens of breeds of dogs. I would call what she's doing nothing but a glorified puppy mill... how could one possibly care for that many dogs, of that many breeds, and that many litters?

Check out the Shiba Inu breed club, and get references to responsible breeders. Trust me, you DO NOT want to end up with a badly bred, badly raised Shiba Inu puppy... talk about a nightmare.
 
Joined
Mar 10, 2008
Messages
34
Likes
0
Points
0
#65
Ok sorry I disappeared for a while.

I found this breeder that lives in Alabama, and am eager to talk to them. They have nice looking dogs, but biased on the website, thats all I know about them.
Hopefully they will respond to me soon.

http://shibainus.marmafarms.com/

So tell me what you think about them.

And I know this is going to sound like I don't care, and sound like I
am trying to support bad breeders...
But about hestekinhills....

Buying a puppy from her is no different than buying from someone who puts classifieds of unregistered puppies in the newspaper right? My mother bought our ChowChow from a petstore, and also bought a 'purebred' (no he wasn't..) dalmatian from some amish family who put an add in the newspaper.

Now, doesn't this litter of puppies from her, have the same chance of being healthy, as either of my other two dogs? They were both great dogs, and I believe my Chow "Sheba" lived to be 13 which if I'm correct is the right age for this breed. And the only problem we had with either dogs, was we didn't get the chow fixed and she got some problem with her 'parts' and they had to be removed by emergency procedure. Which could have been prevented. And now I will never have an 'unfixed' dog or cat again.

I want to believe she's a good person, maybe she's not a super quality breeder I'll give you that, but I've seen plenty pictures of her kids with the dogs, the dogs with other dogs, and all the pictures the dogs are INSIDE with TOYS and BLANKETS. This doesn't seem like a typical puppy mill to me.
And she does have 6 breeds on her website, but she only has puppies from the basenjis, the shibas, and the mutts.
The birds are her friends birds, she said she was advertising, and she said she co-owns the breeding adults...which I don't really understand either...

I'm NOT trying to support puppy mills, I just don't think she is ALL THAT BAD of a breeder.

Anyway, I'm still looking for opinions on the other breeder. She has 2 puppies on puppyfind too....
But I also don't believe ALL the puppies on that website come from irresponsible breeders/puppymills.
 

Beanie

Clicker Cult Coordinator
Joined
May 17, 2006
Messages
14,012
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
39
Location
Illinois
#66
Buying a puppy from her is no different than buying from someone who puts classifieds of unregistered puppies in the newspaper right?
Pretty much. Also no different than buying from someone who puts classifieds of registered puppies in the newspaper.

Now, doesn't this litter of puppies from her, have the same chance of being healthy, as either of my other two dogs?
Sure.
Now, don't you want a dog who has a FAR GREATER chance of being healthy than dogs bought from a puppymill or BYB..?


There are many of us on this board who know all too well the heartache of a dog bought from a less than reputable breeder.
YES, there may be nothing wrong with a puppy bought from a breeder of that woman's caliber. YES, even a puppy from the most reputable breeder might have a disease or health problem pop up and you might go through the same thing.
Buy why oh why oh WHY would you not do everything in your power to reduce your chances of having to endure that kind of heartbreak?

We have gone through it. You do not have to.

Do you understand...? It doesn't matter if she's not the worst breeder in the world. It doesn't matter if she doesn't fit your mental image of what a puppymill might look like. It doesn't matter.
That does not make her any BETTER of a breeder.
 

mrose_s

BusterLove
Joined
Mar 27, 2005
Messages
12,169
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
34
Location
QLD, Australia
#67
Not all mills are gonna be the worst, and whether she is a mill or just a BYB it still isn't good.

Sure her dogs might be loved and well looked after, but they just arn't breeding quality and there are things about her that mean she probably shouldn't be breeding.

The only reason to breed a dog is if there is a good chance the next generation will improve the breed for the better, and there are clues on the website that make methink that isn't her aim.

IMO a good breeder shjoudl knwo their breeds standard back to front and inside out, you get into a lot of breeds and its hard to know exactly what your looking at (someof those standards and pages and pages long plus you need a good amount of experience in teh breed to be able to understand some of how the standard is writen)

No she's not the worst breeder, but that doesn't mean I would take a pup from her.

Plus the fact that she breeds mixes disgusts me, honeslty, the DD issue does NOT need anymore support.

Keep looking around, once you find a relaly good breeder it'll be worth it!

ETA
There is always the chance you'll get a healthy dog from a bad breeder. But there is a big chance your dog won't be. Harry was from a BYB.
2 years old, very sever hip dysplasia, he's had a few nights where I think "omg, he just isn't going to be able to walk by tomorow" we don't think he can see very well. And he's only 2. I do wonder if he'll make it to be 5 or 6 years old. It's not worth the risk to support someone that could be bringing poor suffering souls like Harry into the world.
 
Joined
Mar 10, 2008
Messages
34
Likes
0
Points
0
#68
I really don't want an unhealthy puppy.
I know it's a good idea for breeders to aim to make EVERY dog of that breed meet the breed standards, but honestly, as long as it's a shiba inu, with the shiba personality, and looks like a small fluffball, i could care less if it meets standards, as long as it's HEALTHY.

And thanks to the comments here, I am looking for other breeders, though I have not ruled this one out, despite the warnings...I know that seems stupid on my part...
But I know she could be much worse, and theres still something that keeps me interested.

But again I ask, can you check out this breeder here and tell me what you think?

This one is actually in my state and only 3.5 hours away.
Her dogs look MUCH better too, though no other information is given. I am awaiting an e-mail with a plethora of questions from them though.

http://shibainus.marmafarms.com/

She breeds 3-4 different breeds, no mixes, and it looks like she only has 2 shiba puppies at the moment, both of about 4 months old. And possibly another litter on the way (At least I'm hoping!)
 
Joined
Mar 10, 2008
Messages
34
Likes
0
Points
0
#69
I'm sorry for Harry. My Chow had a VERY mild case of it, maybe 4 months before she died.

She was suprisingly healthy for a pet store dog fed Iams her whole life.

Oh does anyone feed Maxximum Nutrition dog food?
Its about 16 dollars a bag, and got good ratings 8/10, and has never been recalled.
Was wondering if anyone had good or bad remarks on it.
I can't afford 30$ bags of dog food or a raw food diet. But I'm trying to get a higher grade for my budget type of food.
 

Zoom

Twin 2.0
Joined
Jul 11, 2005
Messages
40,739
Likes
3
Points
38
Age
41
Location
Denver, CO
#70
You'll actually get more for your money with the higher grade stuff. When I feed Innova, it's $45 for a 33lb bag. I feed a combined total of 125 lbs of dog out of it and it lasts me over a month. The caloric density is greater in the higher quality foods and since there are fewer to no "fillers" the dog's get more out of each bit and thus you don't have to feed as much.

If you're super concerned about budget though, Costco's Kirkland Signatures Chicken and Rice formula is a pretty good one (it's basically Diamond's "Chicken Soup" repackaged) and it's $20 for a 40lb bag. I'm feeding a bag of this at the moment because I had a budget crunch and could only afford $20 for dog food. I'm going through it a little faster because the calories are lower. It's still a good food, but I'm having to feed more of it than I was the Innova...their poops are larger and more smelly on this in comparison, but nothing like they would be if I was feeding Maxx. Nutrition or Iams or anything like that. I shudder at the thought!
 

IliamnasQuest

Loves off-leash training!
Joined
Feb 28, 2006
Messages
1,083
Likes
0
Points
0
#72
A bit about health testing for the original poster:

The information the breeder is giving on health testing is exactly what BAD breeders say about their dogs. "They've always been healthy so there's no need to health test", etc. No one should ever buy from a breeder who fails to do the genetic health testing on their breeding stock. It's not a gray area - breeders who don't health test do NOT have the good of the breed in mind.

Shibas, at a minimum, should be certified through a reputable organization (OFA, OVC, PennHip) for hips and elbows. This means that after the age of two years, the dogs are taken to a veterinarian and x-rays are taken of the joints, and then those x-rays are sent off to the appropriate specialists to be assessed and graded. Dogs who are showing any sort of degenerative joint disease will be identified and then breeders can avoid breeding more health problems into the dogs. There is NO WAY to truly identify these problems except through proper testing.

I took a look at the OFA site (www.offa.org) to check for "Hestekin" shibas - there's only one listed and all they checked for was hips. And it's not the dog they have listed on the website. Other than that, no Hestekin shibas have been health tested in any way (and OFA is the largest testing organization, so if she was doing any testing it would most likely be through OFA).

When you look at a website, the very first thing you should look for is health clearances. They should list the OFA numbers right on the site so that you can check them out yourself. GOOD breeders are very proud of their dogs and the health clearances. And then to prove breed worthiness and temperament there should be some sort of titles/certifications (breed conformation, obedience, agility, therapy dog, etc.). If you don't find health clearances, there is NO valid reason to buy from that breeder. All you will be doing is financing the further breeding of untested, usually poor quality dogs.

In looking at the Hestekin website, I can't find one thing that I find to be positive about that breeder. The shibas she has photos of are cute, but do not look to be of high quality. Breeders like this depend on people thinking with their hearts instead of their heads, so they fill pages full of cutesy photos and hope that someone is naive enough to fall for that.

I haven't looked at the second site you posted, but if you go there and the health clearances are not plainly stated (including certification NUMBERS) then I could never recommend that you buy from them either. You need to start with health and go from there.

As to your questions on having had a healthy non-tested dog previously - yes, it's possible to get a puppy from untested stock and have it be completely healthy. But the success rate is MUCH lower than it is with properly tested dogs. You run a higher risk of problems - and it's just not worth it, especially when you're paying that kind of money! That first breeder is asking exorbitant amounts of money for untested, low quality dogs.

You'd be better off going through a shiba rescue site and getting a rescue dog.

Melanie and the gang in Alaska
 
Joined
Mar 10, 2008
Messages
34
Likes
0
Points
0
#73
Thank you for that link to search for health checks. :)

I searched the other breeder, they tested 1 of their Shibas. And all of their Shetlands..
Wonder why.
 

lizzybeth727

Active Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2007
Messages
6,403
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Central Texas
#75
Buying a puppy from her is no different than buying from someone who puts classifieds of unregistered puppies in the newspaper right? My mother bought our ChowChow from a petstore, and also bought a 'purebred' (no he wasn't..) dalmatian from some amish family who put an add in the newspaper.
I agree with you here. But it's also no different than adopting a dog from a shelter or breed rescue group. At least if you're adopting you're preventing a pet from being euthanized. I checked petfinder.com, they have listings of 313 Shibas - of course many of those are mixes - and I typed in an Alabama area code and browsed through them. Many are purebred (best anyone can tell), and many are in shelters marked "Urgent" - time's almost up.

http://www.petfinder.com/search/sea...nu&pet.Age=&pet.Size=&pet.Sex=&location=35209

I know that my soapbox is adopting, but it's hard to argue when you don't mind spending hundreds of dollars on a dog, flying up to get him, and all that, after you know it's not a good breeder.
 

noludoru

Bored Now.
Joined
Dec 22, 2006
Messages
17,830
Likes
8
Points
38
Location
Denver, CO
#76
Hey Failurebydesign (do you have a nickname? can I call you FBD?).... I'd listen to Melanie, she gave you some REALLY good information about health testing and what you should be looking for. :)

The thing is... that breeder is charging $900 for limited registration of a Shiba, and $1,700 for breeding rights (I hesitate to say show quality, because I don't know Shibas and have never been to a show, but I've seen what show quality Shibas look like; and they are in no way shape or form show quality no matter how blind the judge is). You're going to pay something like that for just about any Shiba you buy, and probably more for a dog from a pet store and much much less for a rescue. I'll break it down a bit..

Shiba from rescue:
Cost: $80-300, depending on the rescue, the dog's age, health conditions, etc. If they're charging more than $300, I doubt they are truly a rescue.
What you get: A dog who is probably from a puppy mill or BYB, and has no guarantee on health. The dog has been spayed/neutered/vaccinated and given veterinary attention if it's needed, and will probably be temperament tested and most likely has received at least some basic training. You'll have help from the rescue for the rest of your dog's life if you need it, and they will be able to recommend trainers and vets in your area.

Shiba from BYB:
Cost: $500-$2,000
What you get: A dog who may or may not have had socialization and vet care, whose parents are BYBred or puppy mill dogs who may or may not be healthy. You're paying a heck of a lot for a dog you can get at a rescue for much, much cheaper.

Shiba from pet store:
Cost: $1,500-$2,500 (or more, but then it really depends on where you live - the pet store near me that just closed is in the middle of nowhere in the country and still had a market for $3,000 dogs; I'd imagine pet stores in Cali and NY could charge more, for instance)
What you get: A dog who has most likely been bred in a puppy mill, at best a litter from a BYB who couldn't sell. The dog may or may not have papers, and if it does come with papers they could be fakes. (Besides, papers mean absolutely NOTHING without information about the dog's ancestors... it's just a bunch of names of dogs who were trapped in tiny cages and bred until they couldn't breed anymore.) The puppy has received little to no socialization, and much of that has not been positive. The dog is probably not healthy and most likely has never seen a vet or been vaccinated, and definitely has not been fed a decent food. No health certifications from parents, questionable temperament, and god knows what else. You COULD get a perfectly fine dog, sure, but talk to all the people that haven't, and judge whether you're willing to take that risk for yourself, especially with the amount of money you'll be forking over.

Shiba from reputable breeder:
Cost: $800-1,500 (I'm estimating based on the *few* prices I could find and what I know to be usual for other breeds, because with Shibas I'm really not sure. I haven't read the entire thread and maybe somewhere along the line someone else found the average price for well-bred Shiba Inus)
What you get: At a minimum a 3-generation pedigree, hopefully more; a dog who has the best possible chance of being healthy due to parents and at least grandparents as well having health certifications. A Shiba who fits the breed standard in both temperament, gait, and looks; who is well socialized and well adjusted, and constant support from the breeder for the lifetime of your dogs and even beyond that, a real friend who will do his or her best to help you, because he/she truly cares about the dogs. You get a dog who has had the best possible start in life and well on its way to becoming a companion you can share your life with for a decade or more.


What Shiba Web has to say about reputable breeders...
Does that breeder seem to know his breed? (Here is where your research is invaluable.) Do you know more about this breed than the breeder does? Does he breed his dogs with that AKC standard in mind? That AKC standard is the "blueprint" for that breed. Suppose you always wanted a house with a front porch. You picked out a builder and gave him a blueprint of exactly what you wanted. When you come to see your house the porch is on the back. When you question the builder he tells you that he didn’t like the way it was on the blueprint so he built the house "His Way!". Are you going to be very happy with that builder or that house?
Does he guarantee his puppies? Is it just for health or for other problems also? Is he aware of the genetic problems in his breed (every breed has them) and is he screening his dogs for those problems? Are you buying a "pet" or a "show". If you are buying a "pet", why is it a "pet"? If you are buying a "show" is it guaranteed to show, to point, to finish? If you are unable to keep the dog will the breeder take it back? Just look at the adds in the newspaper. Everyday you will usually see at least one add that reads "Moving", "Child Allergic", or "Needs room to run". If he does have a guarantee, is it written and is the breeder willing to sign it. Remember, unless you bring a witness along with you, it’s your word against the breeder.
The bit in red is what especially disturbed me about your breeder, as they're selling dogs as show quality when they clearly are not, and someone else already covered the "health guarantees" and we've all been talking about conformation, so I wont elaborate more. They even have an entire page devoted to health topics in Shibas.

This is what the National Shiba Club of America has to say about responsible breeders, and they have a long list on their page. This is what you should be looking for in a breeder when you see their website and their Shiba's brags about their titles, loads of info on Shibas, and a distinct absence of many litters in the last year or two. I don't see anything on that particular site's health certs, but I bet if you looked more thoroughly than I did or shot them an e-mail you'd find them. This site has health certs on at least one dog, three generation pedigrees, show brags, etc on their site. Again, what you should be looking for.

The National Shiba Club of America also has this to say...
Red flags:

# A breeder who says his dogs don't need the health checks or refuses to show you any health certification.

# Breeders who have puppies in several different breeds.

# Breeders who breed "designer dogs" such a Labradoodles or peek-a-poos. These are mutts and anyone who buys them is really being taken to the cleaners.
Sorry for the frighteningly long post, but I hope it helps! :)
 

Cheza

New Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2007
Messages
1,278
Likes
0
Points
0
#79
To the OP, lots of fantastic advice given.
I hope you can find a great breeder in your area!
 

adojrts

New Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
4,089
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ontario, Canada
#80
I feel that several people on Chaz have researched the breeder, the breed and the health testing and given excellent advice based on years of experience. Whether that experience be as a rep. breeder/handler, purchasing or from having bad experiences from such places. I harzard to guess that we have invested more on this topic than the OP. Who despite of all this solid advice is still thinking of supporting that breeder. And is finding ways to justify such a purchase.
We wasted our time............but at least we tried.
 

Members online

Top