I've never seen VS, so no comment there. The only thing about Brad I agree with is telling families to get off their butts and take responsibility for their dog's problems. I don't like the way he treats the animals; Dogs understand the "or else" tone and aren't following direction because they trust him, they seem timid. As for Cesar, I like his books better than his show. The basic pshycology works: be confident and in charge, and your dogs will gladly follow! I didn't get how my lack of confidence diminished their faith in me. No talk, no touch, no eye contact seems mean. Marlee would be sick with neglect in hours if I didn't lovingly pat her head whenever I went by and that would NOT improve her behavior!