I don't think many of us that have allowed our cats to go outside (especially when living in the country) think that they are disposable, its just because that is the way it has always been.
...
But the question is why has it always been like this. What is the mentality, the unstated assumptions, that allowed this status quo to develop and continue? Could it possibly be because cats were/are at a subconscious level deemed by society to be inferior to dogs, somehow warranting less protection? Just food for thought.
Also, Dizzy and some of the others who have no problem letting their cats roam because, for example,they come back home at night, etc.
I am going to break down this argument and if you could please tell me whether you agree or disagree with the following, that would be good:
1. We cannot guarantee that our cats will come home at night. Agree or disagree?
2. There is always a chance that if they are out there unsupervised, that harm will befall them. Agree or disagree? (Forget about the property damage issues right now, not that they are not important but for now I want to ascertain your position on risks to THEIR well being).
3. if you have agreed with number 2 above, and you still allow your cats outdoors unsupervised, then presumably you are prepared to take the chance. Please tell me WHY you are prepared to take that chance:
a) Because the risk of your cat getting poisoned by an asshole is minimal
b) Because the risk of your cat getting seriously injured by wild animals is minimal
c) Because the risk of your cat getting hit by a car or killed or injured for any other reason is minimal
d) Because the risk of your cat getting injured (which you acknowledge) is outweighed by the fact that if he lives indoors, he has no quality of life and it is cruel. He will be bored, etc etc.
e) All of the above.
f) How do your respond to the following statement: Even if their is a slight risk, it is too much of a risk because our cats our precious members of our family, and we should keep them stimulated happy and healthy in a manner that does not ential said risk. Isnt any risk of losing your beloved family member and friend to a brutal violent death TOO much of a risk? May I hear some responses to this specific question please.
If you agree with the statement in D above, please consider these questions:
1. There are many ways to keep your cat stimulated and happy, active and busy INDOORS.
2. You can always take a bit of time to spend with your cat outdoors, supervised. We spend time walking our dog, so why not spend some time giving our cats their outdoor time SUPERVISED?
3. Finally, please answer this question. Why do you choose to let your cat out UNSUPERVISED as opposed to SUPERVISED outdoor time? Is it a lack of time? Too busy? Cannot be bothered? Other? Please explain if you care to.
Thanks.