Would you declaw?

Would you declaw?

  • No, never

    Votes: 44 67.7%
  • Yes

    Votes: 11 16.9%
  • Other

    Votes: 10 15.4%

  • Total voters
    65
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
4,107
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
California
This morning I had toast for breakfast, and I went for a wee at about 7am. I forgot to put socks on too.
lol

I can tell you this summer I will be getting several more fosters, and for sure we always end up permanently keeping a few. And guess what? NONE will be declawed!!
 

noludoru

Bored Now.
Joined
Dec 22, 2006
Messages
17,830
Likes
8
Points
38
Location
Denver, CO
RTH - about the TVs... have you tried to make a barrier around them? It sounds crazy, but it has worked for me before. I've used cardboard and stuff like that, but what worked bast are those square wire things that you put together to make cubbies. You can wire them together as a 'fence' of sorts. Cats usually wont climb on unstable things - especially not ones that make a racket - so it could probably protect your TV well. Another option is the thick wire screens you can get from hardware stores.

None of those items look pretty, but I am sure something would work for you.
 

Dizzy

Sit! Good dog.
Joined
Sep 14, 2005
Messages
17,761
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Wales
maybe because you guys respond so fast, I didn't get to reading reading your posts to me seeing I was about 3 pages behind. and probably will be again by the time I post this

I don't have any good benefits other than what it does for me. Why is that so wrong? again I only have one, that was declawed before we got it, and 3 that aren't. I wish 2 of them were does that make me bad. I'm sorry, 2 plasma screens tv's scratched has left me a little pissed, sorry if that is so inhumane of me. I have a feeling i'm not the only one.

and for every "health" benefit there is a detriment. I'm not going to argue that fact with a bunch of people that have themselves convinced that S/N programs are for the benefit of the animal, instead of for population control.

I find all these repsonses about spending time and blah, blah blah, funny, because I doubt any of you spend more time with your animals on fun and training than I do. Maybe a few come close. Anybody rip the carpet out of a perfectly good room, take out the cloth furniture and and put up french doors with all glass so one of your cats that had no health issues, still had its claws but liked to pee on the steps and couches, could still be upstairs in its own room and you could still see him while watching TV. (forgive me again that I don't spend every waking moment with the cat that pees, but I did remodel an entire room for the cat so he wouldnt' get dumped on somebody else or PTS) But I guess my motives were purely selfish, I didn't like the pee'd on couch smell. But I could also argue your reasons for even having a cat are selfish, so why even have that arguement.
Sorry, but you were the one comparing the two procedures, I just wondered how they could be compared as they are not even remotely for similar things.

And cat owners put up with **** a lot of the time.

If you don't LIKE it, don't get a cat.

My own cat took to pissing on beds for awhile, and on piles of clothes. And bringing dead mice to my room.

My mums cat sh1t in my sisters bed while she was IN it. If you locked Simba in a room by accident, he'd remove the carpet and pee wherever he liked. He also took to marking the house when I returned home with my cat and dog.

Did they get declawed or bungs up their arses? Hell no........ we invested in cleaner, ensured we check a room before we leave, seperated the cats at feeding time to reduce stress etc etc etc...

And no, we don't all have loads of time.
 
Joined
Jan 31, 2006
Messages
6,444
Likes
0
Points
36
We had Tuppence, and she was mentalist. She left home one day and never returned :(
how did she get out? if you train a cat well enough they will not get out... if you love your cat enough you will not let them live outside. <TONGUE IN CHEEK HERE>

the point isnt for you to go through each and every one of your cats... the point was I am sure there is something you and every single other person here does with their pets that I dont agree with or hounds, or beth doesnt agree with... I dont know what happened to your cat, I dont know if she slipped out when someone opened the door, or she was allowed out, and you dont need to say, it doesnt matter... the fact that you lost a cat this way doesnt make me think you love your animals any less. Eveybody does something with their animals that other people dont agree with... as long as people are killing their animals or neglecting them why should it matter?
 

noludoru

Bored Now.
Joined
Dec 22, 2006
Messages
17,830
Likes
8
Points
38
Location
Denver, CO
how did she get out? if you train a cat well enough they will not get out... if you love your cat enough you will not let them live outside.
And here I thought the solution to not letting the cats out was verbally beating the parents into submission. Dang. There goes my fun. :rofl1:
 
Joined
Jan 31, 2006
Messages
6,444
Likes
0
Points
36
because cats are allowed outside, doesn't mean they are forced to LIVE outside.
sorry i typed that fast, I meant go outside not live outside... it was a typo.

Many people dont agree with cats even going outside... I am sure more cats die each day from going outside than die from declawing procedures.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2008
Messages
4,381
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Midwest
RTH - about the TVs... have you tried to make a barrier around them? It sounds crazy, but it has worked for me before. I've used cardboard and stuff like that, but what worked bast are those square wire things that you put together to make cubbies. You can wire them together as a 'fence' of sorts. Cats usually wont climb on unstable things - especially not ones that make a racket - so it could probably protect your TV well. Another option is the thick wire screens you can get from hardware stores.

None of those items look pretty, but I am sure something would work for you.
I did think about the screen thing, but didn't do it yet. Both were scratched before I got the idea anyway. Actually I'm thinking of building a book case/entertainment case around it, and setting the TV back just enough so there is no ledge for them to be enticed into jumping on.
 

Dizzy

Sit! Good dog.
Joined
Sep 14, 2005
Messages
17,761
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Wales
My cats are free to use the cat flap.

Like I said, my cats NEED their claws to climb trees, eat birds and scratch up the neighbours shed.

You will find the majority of the cats in the UK are not house cats.

I hate to see cats indoors all the time, but that is a WHOLE other debate.

And for the record, on cat training - all of ours come to a bell ;)
 

Giny

Active Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2005
Messages
5,544
Likes
4
Points
38
Location
Maine
With me mentioning in my prior post that vets seem to have a different approach on the subject of declawing compared to when I first got my cat declawed 20 years ago, they don't seem to push the procedure in my face, made me take a look at my vets website.

On their site I did see them mentioning a newer procedure called DDFT, Deep Digital Flexor Tenotomy. Where instead of amputating the finger digit, only the main flexor tendon of each digit is severed. So the cat is unable to retract their claws.

I wouldn't consider it for my cat, but as an alternative to declawing I think it's better. You still need to clip their nails, and I'd think it would be an obligatory clipping since the cat wouldn't be able to shed the old nails since they can't extract the nail...sounds sad when you think of it. Still, better then complete removal. No?
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2008
Messages
4,381
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Midwest
Sorry, but you were the one comparing the two procedures, I just wondered how they could be compared as they are not even remotely for similar things.

actually they are. I brought up the reasons pages ago, but some big similarities are #1 it's surgery. #2 one can use a local and a laser, the other cuts out organs and uses anesthesia that can kill the animal. #3 they are both done for human convenience. There are more similarities, but I thought I'd just touch on the big 3 so to speak.

And cat owners put up with **** a lot of the time.

If you don't LIKE it, don't get a cat.

My own cat took to pissing on beds for awhile, and on piles of clothes. And bringing dead mice to my room.

But we do have cats 4 of them at present, many more over the years. I know what cat owners have to put up with, add a couple working dogs in there too and a few fosters or dogs in for training just for good measure. What's your point? I don't like cat **** on my bed so i'm a bad person?

My mums cat sh1t in my sisters bed while she was IN it. If you locked Simba in a room by accident, he'd remove the carpet and pee wherever he liked. He also took to marking the house when I returned home with my cat and dog.

Did they get declawed or bungs up their arses? Hell no........ we invested in cleaner, ensured we check a room before we leave, seperated the cats at feeding time to reduce stress etc etc etc...

who's sticking bungs up asses? and what is a bung??? I've heard of a bung hole, but then why stick a butthole in a butthole?

I guess because i remodeled a room and make the cat stay in there, i'm somehow a less worthy cat owner than those that accept the cat pissing on the beds and couches and steps etc? I guess I'll wear that distinction, no problem.


And no, we don't all have loads of time.

I guess I had to had something extra so it would post because it doesn't recognize my words in your quote.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2008
Messages
4,381
Likes
0
Points
36
Location
Midwest
all of ours come to their name, I want to know how to keep them off the wall, and no i'm not buying poly to coat my walls. They'd probably just find it fun to slide down. if we let them outside they'd be dead on the road in less than a year, and old declawed cat Tasha was almost 18 and was bringing birds home weekly till she was gone ( I lived in a rural area when I was growing up)
 

ACooper

Moderator
Joined
Jan 7, 2007
Messages
27,772
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
IN
If the cat is in a happy home living to a ripe old age I have no issue with people doing it. In fact I find it LESS cruel than people who allow their cats outside to save their home from "that litterbox smell" or because they think the cat "needs" it.

So there ya go.
I think this about covers it people.

There are some of you arguing against declawing who let/leave your beloved pet outside to face hazards more frightening and dangerous than having been declawed.

I am not telling you not to do so..........but let me tell you there are MANY who would. They think leaving your cat outside unattended is cruel and taking unnecessary risks. As many cats as I see with little collars on laying on the side of the road weekly, I can't say those people against it are wrong.

I do believe we have had threads right here on chaz arguing the point as well.

What it comes down to? It's YOUR animal, YOUR choice, and no amount of arguing back and forth is going to change any of your minds. Period.
 
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
4,107
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
California
But, this is a debate thread. It obviously was meant to be. I see no harm in people voicing their opinions, or concerns for that matter.

No harm in a little debate.
 

ACooper

Moderator
Joined
Jan 7, 2007
Messages
27,772
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
IN
But, this is a debate thread. It obviously was meant to be. I see no harm in people voicing their opinions, or concerns for that matter.

No harm in a little debate.
Who said there was harm in it? Not me.

I just see a few getting a little carried away by the tide and wanted to remind them that they aren't going to change minds that way ;)

Don't look for censorship where there is none :)
 

noodlerubyallie

Sprayin' the spiders
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
1,181
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Iowa
Coop and HBH: :hail::D Thank you, you both said it so much better than I could, the six times I tried to write a polite and insightful reply.

There is no harm in debate. However, I think the condescending tone of some of the responses leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

I think we've successfully "debated" the topic into a circle ;)
 

noludoru

Bored Now.
Joined
Dec 22, 2006
Messages
17,830
Likes
8
Points
38
Location
Denver, CO
I did think about the screen thing, but didn't do it yet. Both were scratched before I got the idea anyway. Actually I'm thinking of building a book case/entertainment case around it, and setting the TV back just enough so there is no ledge for them to be enticed into jumping on.
You might also be able to buy the kind you can install in the walls. I dunno how expensive that is, though, so it might be a silly idea.

Another idea for the entertainment center - one with doors, so you can close it.
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top