Women fined for drunk Chihuahua

Joined
Feb 13, 2006
Messages
313
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
40
#4
I'll just copy and paste it:

Woman fined $100 for drunk dog

By Jeff Long
Tribune staff reporter
Published May 22, 2006, 8:33 PM CDT


No strangers to testifying in drunken-driving cases, two Island Lake police officers found themselves in unusual circumstances Monday when they described the telltale effects of alcohol on a chihuahua named Chico.

"I smelled an alcoholic beverage," Officer Matt Duchemin testified. "I observed the dog seem confused and disoriented."

In a McHenry County courtroom usually reserved for traffic citations and petty offenses, the nitty-gritty legal routine of the northwest suburbs, the bench trial also included expert testimony, phone records and the cross-examination of witnesses.

In the end, Circuit Judge John Bolger ruled that Chico was intoxicated while in the care of Diane Marcotte, 50, of Island Lake. He fined her $100 on the misdemeanor charge of failing to provide humane care and treatment for a pet.

"I think it stinks," Marcotte said afterward.

Marcotte still faces a DUI charge and counts of endangering her two children, who were in her car March 13 when police stopped her after she picked up her son at Cotton Creek Elementary School. That case will be in court next month.

Marcotte represented herself in the dispute about her former pet Chico, a 5-month-old puppy that police say was also in the car—and drunk.

The dog has been confiscated and placed with a new owner. Marcotte said she asked for a trial to clear her name.

On March 12, the day before police were called to the school, Marcotte was cleaning out her car about 8:30 p.m., she testified

She told Bolger that she took a glass of wine into the garage and must have left it in the car.

The following afternoon, Chico bounced into the garage, apparently eager to ride along when Marcotte left to pick her son up from school.

"Chihuahuas are very hyper dogs," Marcotte said. "He jumped into the car and knocked the glass of wine over."

Marcotte said she went to the kitchen to get a towel, and when she returned the dog was shaking in a sort of "seizure." She testified that she picked up the dog and ran into the house. "I asked Chico, 'Are you ok?'" she said.

Unable to reach her vet, she called an emergency veterinary service in Crystal Lake, which advised her to bring the dog in for examination, she testified. Marcotte produced phone records in court showing those calls.

Eager to get help for Chico, she told the judge she drove past the line of school buses and up onto the sidewalk at the school to get her son as quickly as possible.

"It was an emergency, in my opinion," she said.

School officials called police, who conducted field sobriety tests and arrested her on the DUI and child endangerment charges. Marcotte was charged with DUI again the following week in Hoffman Estates.

Island Lake Police Officers Duchemin and Andrew Klem testified that they smelled alcohol on the breath of both Marcotte and Chico.

"The dog was shaking vigorously," Klem told the judge. "It did have a strong odor of alcohol emitting from its breath."

McHenry County Animal Control Officer Sean Graff arrived at the school and wrapped Chico in a towel. In court, he described the dog as "lethargic" and "whimpering."

Veterinarian Alicia Ratni testified that Chico was drunk. Under cross-examination by Marcotte, she said as little as a tablespoon of an alcoholic beverage could have made the dog tipsy.

Marcotte asked whether dogs often slurp up anything they find on the ground.

"That's a possibility," Ratni answered.

"I was not pouring it into his water bowl," Marcotte said. "The last thing I wanted to do was hurt my dog. And when I saw something was wrong, I was immediately on my way to get help."

[email protected]







Copyright © 2006, Chicago Tribune
 
L

LabBreeder

Guest
#5
that is about the stupidest thing i've ever read!!!
i can't believe the police arrested HER because her dog was "drunk" and sick...and charged HER with child endangerment. it seems like she hadn't even taken a drink of the wine that she'd poured yet, cause chico knocked it over. they probably just arrested her cause the car smelled like alcohol.

she should have been allowed to go to the vet, then if she was lying, the police could have done something if they absolutely felt the need to. how stupid does a cop AND a judge have to be to not see that she was trying to help her dog...and that she had proof she was trying to help it...OMG i'm certainly glad i don't live there.
 
Joined
Jan 31, 2005
Messages
4,003
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
The great whi...err...green(?) North
#6
LabBreeder said:
that is about the stupidest thing i've ever read!!!
i can't believe the police arrested HER because her dog was "drunk" and sick...and charged HER with child endangerment. it seems like she hadn't even taken a drink of the wine that she'd poured yet, cause chico knocked it over. they probably just arrested her cause the car smelled like alcohol.

she should have been allowed to go to the vet, then if she was lying, the police could have done something if they absolutely felt the need to. how stupid does a cop AND a judge have to be to not see that she was trying to help her dog...and that she had proof she was trying to help it...OMG i'm certainly glad i don't live there.
Sounds to me like she was pretty hammered actually:

"School officials called police, who conducted field sobriety tests and arrested her on the DUI and child endangerment charges."
 

MomOf7

Evil Kitty taco eater
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
3,437
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
WA.
#7
School officials called police, who conducted field sobriety tests and arrested her on the DUI and child endangerment charges. Marcotte was charged with DUI again the following week in Hoffman Estates.
Sounds like someone has a problem....
No one has the right to drink and drive and endanger my friends and family.
Call a stinkin cab lady...Much cheaper than the fines and treatment you have to pay for.
 
L

LabBreeder

Guest
#8
it doesn't say if she was actually drunk or not. it just says they did the tests. i know there are some cops that will arrest on the "smell alone"...not just results. that is why i got pissy...if she was drunk that's one thing...if not they should have let her take the dog to the vet. it's the dog i was worried about.
 
Joined
Jan 31, 2005
Messages
4,003
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
The great whi...err...green(?) North
#9
LabBreeder said:
it doesn't say if she was actually drunk or not. it just says they did the tests. i know there are some cops that will arrest on the "smell alone"...not just results. that is why i got pissy...if she was drunk that's one thing...if not they should have let her take the dog to the vet. it's the dog i was worried about.
Understandable :). My first concern would be her ripping into the school zone under the influence though.

To top it all off, I find her story very suspect:

"She told Bolger that she took a glass of wine into the garage and must have left it in the car."

Cars don't have a lot of level surfaces for glasses - and why would she put a glass of wine in the car to begin with? Personally, I think it sounds a bit too far-fetched to be believed. Just my opinion though.
 
L

LabBreeder

Guest
#10
lol @ andrew...true! :)

maybe she was going to clean her car and needed a little "pick me up" lol...
seriously though, if she was drinking then, no she didn't need to be driving anywhere much less picking her kids up from school.

some stories are just silly, stupid and wrong all the way around...:)
 

pitbulliest

Active Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2004
Messages
1,112
Likes
0
Points
36
Age
39
Location
Toronto, Canada
#14
lol this is funny... a woman gets into all this jazz because her dog accidently got into some wine (sure she was an idiot for not supervising the dog, but still?)....while people fighting pit bulls and breeding dogs in puppy mills get away with a slap on the wrist....

Jokes..pure jokes I say...lol
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top