Why I stay out of the training section in guardian breed forums

Sweet72947

Squishy face
Joined
May 18, 2006
Messages
9,159
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Northern Virginia
#1
I joined a Cane Corso forum a while back. I typically stay out of the training sections because it seems like 99.9% if of guardian breed owners believe in dominance theory bullcrap and I just wind up angry. Today, however, I forgot my password and couldn't go look at the members only sections, so I glanced in training forum. I'm sickened.

This is an excerpt from a thread. It is completely disgusting, but not just for the reasons the author thinks. And I don't find it the least bit funny.

Threads like this just reinforces my goal to be a guardian breed owner who trains with intelligent methods.

:(:(


I'm posting this story because I think it will make you laugh AND feel better about what you go through with your dogs, lol.

When I got Luca from rescue, he had a serious problem with submissive/fear based urination. So many things were triggers that scared him into thinking he was going to be abused, and then he would pee. Stuff like eye contact, loud noises, touching his tail or his neck, etc. etc.

The thing about Luca is that he can hold more pee than any dog I have ever encountered. It's like a camel, I don't know where he stores it all. He can pee continuously in a heavy stream for at least 30 seconds (my friend clocked him) and then pee several more times on a walk.

So needless to say I was being very careful about not doing anything to trigger his fear-pee reaction, because I was tired of cleaning up the sofa and carpeting in my little apartment.

After a few months, he got more confident and was peeing less. But at this point, his confidence turned immediately to aggression. SO on the one hand, he would still pee submissively if I acted dominant, but since I was trying to avoid him peeing, I wasn't being dominant enough with him. He would lunge at other dogs and similar aggressive behavior. Outside, I had no problem correcting him. But when we were inside with the wall-to-wall carpet, I hesitated to assert dominace. The worst was rollovers - he would not roll on his back and freaked out if I turned him over.

I talked this over with my trainer, and he said, "Look, the aggression is the far more serious behavior. You have to assert your leadership. If you are afraid of making him pee, you are sending the message that you will let him get away with stuff. You just have to respond to his aggressive behavior, and forget about the peeing." He insisted that the rolloever was the way to show Luca who is boss - and to not let him up from a rollover until he submitted.

OK, I resolved to follow his advice. A few days later, Luca snapped at my other dog and took away her toy. I responded immediately by grabbing him, rolling him onto his back and kneeling over him, as my trainer taught me, holding him down and making eye contact.

So he squirmed and squirmed and as he squirmed, he peed uncontrollably. He had a full bladder, but I had to follow my trainer's advice and not let him up. As I held him down, he sprayed a steady stream right at me, and it seemed like it would never end. As he kept squirming, he was swinging 'the hose' back and forth so it got everywhere.

My jeans were soaked from the waist to the knees. My underwear was soaked. My crotch was soaked in pee. My shirt was soaked. My bra was plastered to my chest with urine. I had dog pee in my hair. Luckily I dodged getting it in my face, but the smell of urine was overpowering. I felt like I'd fallen into a vat of dog pee.

Eventually, Luca made eye contact and submitted. Then I let him up slowly. And immediately ran to the shower!

I had to do the laundry twice, and I ended up throwing away my underwear. It was hard to peel off my body. There was pee dripping off everything. I was in the shower for a long time. It's really hard to get dog pee out of long hair.

Then of course I had to take Luca for a bath, and I had to rent a steam cleaner and clean up the carpet.

The training technique did work, and that was the last time Luca tried to bully my other dog. He also realized that I wasn't going to torture him when I rolled him over, and he calmed down considerably about rollovers after that. Now I can roll him on his back and he just gently relaxes and lets me.

Not long after that, I moved to an apartment with wood floors!
 
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
2,242
Likes
0
Points
0
#3
WOW

so she finally completely shut her dog down... in about a year we'll hear about it biting her face off .

That dog sounds absolutely terrified, and her methods complete abuse. Shame you can't really educate these people. That poor dog.
 

AGonzalez

Not a lurker
Joined
May 30, 2008
Messages
3,702
Likes
0
Points
0
#4
I'm just happy the dog pissed on her, not because it was out of fear, but because it's the only retaliation he could do.
 

corsomom

New Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2005
Messages
438
Likes
1
Points
0
#6
This is so sad. I dont know what Corso forum you found this in but I do see so much of the dominance crap on the one I visit.The above post is beyond anything I have seen and I'm disgusted this person has a dog. How can people be this stupid?
 

Crowsfeet

facetious.
Joined
Jan 19, 2009
Messages
579
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Portland
#7
Do you guys know of any links that completely bash arguments to "dominance training"?

Links that explain how dominance/"alpha-roll" based training can "shut your dog down"?

Links to alternative training methods?

This is all information I need to read/would like to have.

Dominance based training sounds awful :/
Feel free to PM me as well, thank you.
 

Zoom

Twin 2.0
Joined
Jul 11, 2005
Messages
40,739
Likes
3
Points
38
Age
41
Location
Denver, CO
#8
Just take a look around the training section here, mainly anything dealing with Ceasar Milan.
 

Crowsfeet

facetious.
Joined
Jan 19, 2009
Messages
579
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Portland
#9
Yeah, I know. Its just hard to find solid information that isn't watered down by lots of other stuff, if that makes sense. I'm trying to do some independent research right now.. it's just whacky, because I have friends who respect this .."method" of training, but I feel as though it's only because they don't fully understand, or perhaps don't have dogs themselves.
 

Zoom

Twin 2.0
Joined
Jul 11, 2005
Messages
40,739
Likes
3
Points
38
Age
41
Location
Denver, CO
#10
Anything by Patricia McConnell, Karen Pryor, Pat Miller, Suzanne Clothier should at least get you off in the right direction. Jean McDonald as well.
 

Crowsfeet

facetious.
Joined
Jan 19, 2009
Messages
579
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Portland
#11
Thank you!


I know this is a little(or a lotta?) high-jackingish, but I found some really great information to derail the whole dominant/alpha pseudo-training.

(Dog Whisperer, Dog Psychology and Cesar Millan - see Debunking The Dominance Myth - I thought it was great!)

And funny enough, thank you 'Sweet, because if you didn't post this, I would have kept forgetting to look up these things.

Ugh. Isn't it common knowledge that to teach, you can't do so correctly with fear or heightened defenses?
 

corsomom

New Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2005
Messages
438
Likes
1
Points
0
#12
I've posted alot of those links on a couple forums. So many people do not want to know. Some are kinda clueless(the person that knows her Pug is being dominate becouse he runs to her all excited and paws her when she gets home. She jabs him in the neck then to show him she is boss.) Some others actually like having a shut down dog. And others I think it makes them feel powerful to "Dominate" their dog.

One person even said she did not know who this Jean Donaldson person is but its obvious she does not know dogs! Its frustating becouse you want people to know there's a better way.
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top