I know dogs don't dwell on the past. So we're just working on her future. I'm sure she'll come around. I just posted because Craig's feelings seem to be hurt and I want to show him that it's not his fault and it's also not something that cannot be "fixed". As it is, she's sprawled out on the kitchen floor snoring away. And giving her a treat on his way out is a great idea. She does bark when he leaves, but heck...it's 4:30 am and it's dark and all she knows is someone is moving around by the front door. I think I will make some venison jerky and let that be is "special" thing for her. Thanks for the idea!