I fed TOTW for several months, before switching to Acana. I really like TOTW... my only miffs are, on the fish formula, my dogs did start to smell a bit fishy. And they had decent poops, but not as compact and odorless as they are on Acana. Overall, they had nice coats and condition on TOTW and it has a really good reputation that I know of (besides having chicken in every formula).
I really like the fact that Acana's chicken formula also has fish in it. Their coats do get noticeably softer when fish is a top ingredient in their food, I just don't like the fishy odor on a strictly fish diet. But, I'm hyper-sensitive to fish smells. :cry: