would you own a dog-aggressive dog?

skittledoo

Crazy naked dog lady
Joined
Sep 27, 2007
Messages
13,667
Likes
5
Points
38
Age
37
Location
Fredericksburg
:yikes:This thread has me shaking my head... I have to agree with what was said about a dog is a dog is a dog. Human Aggression, Dog Aggression and Prey drive are so very different from each other. I think some people have made some great points and Labra, I hope that you will pick up a book or something and read about dog behaviors in order to understand the difference between these various forms of aggression and prey drives.
 

CharlieDog

Rude and Not Ginger
Joined
Jan 31, 2008
Messages
9,419
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Georgia
That's all well and good, but when Ozzy is turned on to a high degree, he is not barking at the squirrel, when he is barking, it is because he is frustrated. When he is intent on the squirrel he is silent. When the squirrel is well and treed, he barks a few times and I call him off. He listens to the call off, every single time. Were I to call him mid chase would he listen? No. I know he wouldn't, because when he is intent on that squirrel, HE CANNOT HEAR ME.
 

smkie

pointer/labrador/terrier
Joined
Dec 16, 2004
Messages
55,184
Likes
35
Points
48
I would not let my dog kill a rat becuase that would give him the chance of being bitten by one IF it could be avoided . Ever bee bitten by a rat? ARe you prepared to teach him the difference between a rat and a raccoon? ENcouraging that behavior is dangerous too. My lab Charlie killed a sewer rat that came in when brush creek flooded. THe animal was enormous, and he must have shook it into everything in the kitchen because there was blood everywhere. I was terrified to look but fortunate that he was not bitten. He was lucky. Why would you do that?
 

skittledoo

Crazy naked dog lady
Joined
Sep 27, 2007
Messages
13,667
Likes
5
Points
38
Age
37
Location
Fredericksburg
I would not let my dog kill a rat becuase that would give him the chance of being bitten by one IF it could be avoided . Ever bee bitten by a rat? ARe you prepared to teach him the difference between a rat and a raccoon? ENcouraging that behavior is dangerous too. My lab Charlie killed a sewer rat that came in when brush creek flooded. THe animal was enormous, and he must have shook it into everything in the kitchen because there was blood everywhere. I was terrified to look but fortunate that he was not bitten. He was lucky. Why would you do that?
but what about dogs that are bred to be ratters? A lot of barns have mice/rat problems use dogs to help eliminate the problem. Without them around the mice/rats found their ways into feed, chewed through tack, etc etc...
 

HoundedByHounds

Oh, it's *you*
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
8,415
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
N Texas, USA
DO they stop chasing squirrels? NO, but they do it in silence.
So your training isn't really about prey drive at all,

only masking some the less pleasant side effects.

BTW...since mine don't bark...I can't imagine not allowing them to run at squirrels in their own yard. Good lawd talk about no fun...that's like me saying my kids have to be all silent at all times when in their own rooms.

Adjorts good post. I also have seen some of the methods used in Beagling to call hounds off other game or inappropriate game and there's no way I'd choose those methods on my own.
 

CharlieDog

Rude and Not Ginger
Joined
Jan 31, 2008
Messages
9,419
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Georgia
I've never encouraged the behavior. Oz gets/got free roam of the house most of the time at night. The rats would be in the kitchen, the cat would corner it, and Oz would kill it. He never got hurt, not one time, and he usually left them as presents for my mother. I know it wasn't the cat killing them, because Oz would have the blood on his paws and face, and the puncture wounds on the rats were too large for the cat. These were house rats, and I don't know what he would do if a sewer rat were to come in, but I'm sure unless I was there, he'd kill it.

And yes, I have been bitten by rats. It sucks, majorly, but it wouldn't phase a dog. It drew blood on me, but I kept it clean and it healed just fine.
 

HoundedByHounds

Oh, it's *you*
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
8,415
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
N Texas, USA
I have been bitten by a rat yes...used to have one as a pet. It hurts...

it hurt Buckwheat when that squirrel she caught bit the heck outta her foot as well. But I have no issue with my dogs killing vermin...anymore than I have a problem with A CAT doing the same. My dogs are not a separate entity from Nature and her rules...any more than I myself am.

smkie...do you also find it horrible and aggressive for cats to kill mice, baby rabbits, birds? Do you think they should also be trained as well to recall off a chase?

Barncats do a valuable service...are the injuries and illnesses they might sustain doing so more okay than if a barn Terrier provides the same? Because they are cats?
 

HoundedByHounds

Oh, it's *you*
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
8,415
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
N Texas, USA
I was terrified to look but fortunate that he was not bitten. He was lucky. Why would you do that?
I wouldnt' say lucky...but perhaps skilled.

He did a great job protecting you and your home from a potentially harmful, and disease bearing pest...IMO.
 

adojrts

New Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
4,089
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ontario, Canada
I would not let my dog kill a rat becuase that would give him the chance of being bitten by one IF it could be avoided . Ever bee bitten by a rat? ARe you prepared to teach him the difference between a rat and a raccoon? ENcouraging that behavior is dangerous too. My lab Charlie killed a sewer rat that came in when brush creek flooded. THe animal was enormous, and he must have shook it into everything in the kitchen because there was blood everywhere. I was terrified to look but fortunate that he was not bitten. He was lucky. Why would you do that?
I ve got a 10 lb Jrt a stupid rat doesn't have a chance a bitting her, let alone my other jrts. :rofl1::rofl1::rofl1:
 

adojrts

New Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
4,089
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ontario, Canada
smkie...do you also find it horrible and aggressive for cats to kill mice, baby rabbits, birds? Do you think they should also be trained as well to recall off a chase?

Barncats do a valuable service...are the injuries and illnesses they might sustain doing so more okay than if a barn Terrier provides the same? Because they are cats?

:hail: Excellent point.
 

bcmoffatt

totally normal
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
706
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ontario
Urg. Mind blowing.

Dogs are dogs. Not furry little people. You can't deny what they are, or where they came from.

How's this?
One of my dogs loves to kill small animals. He can be called off, and will drop any thing on command, but the animal is usually dead before I realize what's happening. Is he a monster?

ETA- He will not kill cats. He's caught a few...
 

smkie

pointer/labrador/terrier
Joined
Dec 16, 2004
Messages
55,184
Likes
35
Points
48
I Don't mind them chasing squirrels, it harms nothing. Would they stop mid run..give me a couple more months with Pepper and that answer will be yes. Will VIctor look to me first to see if it is OK that he go? YEs. DAily, everyday, always. I never said eradicate the drive, i said control and direct. ALL hunting dogs should learn to do this. ALL dogs should learn to do this. IT is exhausting and maddening, as maddening as it was to teach VIctor to carry a bucket for a half hour, but do it he did, and he enjoyed himself and the growth of his knowledge, and it deepened our relationship. I am not stating anything here that i have not put into practice as i was taught intially. Bird dogs stop on a whistle mid run ALL The time. Takes some trainers a shock collar to get there, my boss had many different ways of approaching the problem without that kind of force but we did have a collar for the most extreme cases. I would slap one on any dog i thought was going to kill the next door neighbor's cat and watch him like a hawk every second he had access before i thought my dog would harm it. I don't like to train with choke collars and believe them completly rediculous, but i do not have the energy because of illness to chase Pepper about. So we do use a collar for her most dangerous of all hurdle and that is running and refusal to come. SHe does a lot of sitting in the very far corner of the yard staring down the greenway but she isnt' stepping over AN INVISBILE LINE. THEre is no fence there. I have to be aware of her every second she is out there, and thanks to gRAmmy and the bell, i can weed with both eyes now. I have the best weeded garden in town and i can't afford mulch this year becuase i am outside training my freaking dog. I do it because i love her, because i want her to be a success in her life. Because i secretly hope she can help me and Victor raise more money for the humane society this fall. I dont' think i can get her to carry a bucket, but her obed will be sound, and my faith in her 100 percent. SHe is coming along nicely. I don't want to sound like a now it all, i started a thread to let you all know exactly how i learned what i have learned. I didnt' get it out of books, tho i read many, i got it from being around handlers all of my life and seeing what dogs worked willingly and happily and those that did it because of fear. My dogs have always never been the later. You should have seen pepper when she sat on the third..her eyes WANTED to look at that squirrel but i was so in her face. NOt mean, But repeating the same command that she heard at least 10 times on our walk, that always got her good girl praise. IT became more important to her and if you think for one second she wasn't locked on that squirrel like a missle you are wrong. DOgs ARE CAPABLE. THey can learn, it breaks my heart to see how much all of you think they can't. I only know a few things really well. I know how to mix colors. I know how to use a pencil, i know how to move clay around and i know how to reach a dog and help it learn. I only keep coming back to this thread because i am simply horrified that people are letting their animals be such a danger to themselves.

IF the dog kills chickens it dies. If it kills cats? IF it kills another dog? Training against that should be single owner's primary effort with their dog to ensure that bad things do not happen. A dog that is possessive needs to learn not to be. AS one man that had that dvd i watched part of it...and if you want i will come back with the link and the source. HE said "i will let you play with my toys but they are always my toys". EXactly right. TEach that dog that he can't do that to you, or to anyone including the other dogs. IF he chases cats, teach him not to, it isn't that hard. AN older dog is tricky, how old it is IMO does make a difference. Pepper was on the edge of being hit by a car, or pts by animal control. No one would have kept this dog with what she did. I had to, and it is exhausting but oh my is she ever blossoming. THe reward is all mine and i celebrate her accomplishments with my every being. I am not saying you can take a DA dog and i have explained enough what i think that is. But labeling a dog that curls a lip, or gets in a slap fest is wrong. THat is a dog, being a dog. Not a certain breed,,,breed means they may be more alpha, they may be more territorial, it means that someone that really wants this specific animal is going to have to take the proper time and trouble to ward off aggressive behavior. A truly mad animal and they are out there, i could no more help then i could a human with a mental illness. Only then would i become a prison gaurd. i am not doing that to myself or the other canines in my family for that is how i see them, Mary is the other Mom. SHe is as human to me and you are.I taught my children, i teach my dogs. A lot of it is really similar in those first years too. YOu don't crap in my house, you don't bark, and for god sake you don't door dodge. You come when your called. YOu shut up when your told to quiet. Heel loose leashed. SIt when your told down when your told and stay until your told to move. AND since they do that, they sleep in my bed, ride in my car, share my food, my friends and my life. I am complimented every where i go and it happened this morning too. THe man smiled at me and said YOu and your dogs..i never saw him before but obviously he has seen me. A car was coming i said sit. They sat. Mary doesnt' have to sit anymore, i wouldn't ask her to hurt her legs, but for pepper nad victor is law. SInce they sat so nicely, i ran a short distance. Probably makes Victor laff at how slow my run is, but he appriciates the effort. WE look at things sometime for a long long time. CAts and busy roads, other dogs, rabbits squirrels..reward is always free time, love and praise. NOt food. IT is a partnership that can only be obtained when the dog hands over the dominance becuase he no longer needs it, and as that man on the video said...i really got to see what his training methods were becuase for his sales pitch i was really impressed, they won't mind a bit. My little dogs behaved just as good as my big dogs. IT made no difference.


Imo opinion cats are only one step away from a wild thing. A dog has been domesticated to a higher point. They are naturally a pack animal and want to follow a leader. A leader teaches the pack what is safest and what is not. A cat is not a pack animal. Apples and oranges again. I reall dont' like cats either but i respect their right to be on this planet and for my dog not to harm them. I tell my dog no, it is a no, and it will always be a no and for some reason, my terriers, my poodle mixes, the rotties, the shepards the dobies, the labs the goldens the brittneys the chessies and so on and on all get that. Why do you think your animal can't? I saw a german man teach his shetlie to never step in teh garden. THat dog would chase a squirrel to that imaginary liine and stop on a dime. Wonder how that german man did that...i learned alot from germans. My old boss was very very german, he still wore leder,,,,i cant remember how to spell it, the leather shorts with suspenders.IT is consistancy and it will win over desire. IT won't erase passion, you have curb that with something bigger and that is loyalty which is obtained by the development of trust between a handler and their animal. You call the shots, not the other way around. I have VIctor border trained, never needed to with mary because i had her from teh beginning and it was a natural progression, i dont' remember teaching her anyway, not the hard core effort it has taken to teach Pepper. I probably spend at least 3 hours a day outside with her in her yard teaching her where she can go and where she cant. Victor knows where he can urinate when we walk and where he can not. WE are polite, we don't do that in front of people's houses or on the city easment. THat is elimental, to not go when you have to go. SO tell me if a dog can learn to be house broken, why can't he learn more? IMO he can your just not teaching "him" in a way that he understands.
 

adojrts

New Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2006
Messages
4,089
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Ontario, Canada
Considering that this thread is about DA, or as it appears aggression in general, I have a few beliefs as to why.
I firmly believe that by suppressing a dogs natural instincts and drives (which ever those drives maybe), actually may cause aggression by frustration.
So instead of suppressing those drives, find a way to let them free, happier and more content dogs = non aggression and lowered DA.
I know in my dogs cases, that when encouraged to follow how they were 'hard wired', the more content they are and the less likely they are to be interested in looking for another outlet.
And then I don't have the to 'hammer' into my dogs that they must behave to what I THINK is acceptable. They are dogs that have been molded by man, funny how man then changes the rules on them after hundreds of years of selective breeding........and then we label them, suppress them and expect THEM to change overnight.
 

HoundedByHounds

Oh, it's *you*
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
8,415
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
N Texas, USA
SHe is as human to me and you are
I don't do that.

It's unfair to me...to hold a dog to a human standard...and IMO and MO only, many dogs lose homes because of this sort of thinking. On one hand you say you treat your dogs like a person..then you start talking about pack leadership and leading your dog. And "telling" them what's acceptable.

I do not lead my kids...I teach them...I expect them one day to make THEIR OWN decisions...apart from my directions, and I expect that, on occasion, their decisions to run COUNTER to my own wishes.

Which is is...smkie?

my poodle mixes, the rotties, the shepards the dobies, the labs the goldens the brittneys the chessies
All of the above have an innate desire to please...makes things so much easier...doesn't it? What sort of Terrier did you have?
 

smkie

pointer/labrador/terrier
Joined
Dec 16, 2004
Messages
55,184
Likes
35
Points
48
Considering that this thread is about DA, or as it appears aggression in general, I have a few beliefs as to why.
I firmly believe that by suppressing a dogs natural instincts and drives (which ever those drives maybe), actually may cause aggression by frustration.
So instead of suppressing those drives, find a way to let them free, happier and more content dogs = non aggression and lowered DA.
.
THen Victor ought to be the most aggressive dog around and nothing is further from the truth. Mary too. Both are field breed to the 10th degree.I disagree. Freedom is earned by good behavior. Good behavior gets less frustration for all people and animals involved and peace is what a pack animal craves. A dog that has handed over the ropes to you, has more freedom and less DA. He doesnt' need it, your there to handle it.

Frustration comes from confinement, lack of exercise, and lack of leadership because the dog tries to rule the roost and there is no consistancy. It sets ut up for a constant battle of wills.

TEll me please waht you would have done with Pepper...her door dodging running the neighborhood was her hard wired way of thinking. Her terrier stubborness made it so that she didnt' want to give that up. Would you have let her run like my neighbor does with his dog at night so she could get into trash and create havoc for cars? She has to learn to stay on 2 acres without invisible fence, without a marker of any sorts. No one wanted her. I tried for months. But each day we slugged it out and it did take keeping my eye on her 100 percent of the time outside. NOw she is gloriously happy. THe change in her is night and day. HER dog instinct was to run, but love and hard work brought her into the fold, something she had never experienced before i believe. NOw she WANTS to be with us. My friend Logan that walks them cant' believe the change. Now people look at her and she is not the blink blink dog that walks by herself, she is confident and happy and finally Content!
 

Sweet72947

Squishy face
Joined
May 18, 2006
Messages
9,159
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Northern Virginia
Considering that this thread is about DA, or as it appears aggression in general, I have a few beliefs as to why.
I firmly believe that by suppressing a dogs natural instincts and drives (which ever those drives maybe), actually may cause aggression by frustration.
So instead of suppressing those drives, find a way to let them free, happier and more content dogs = non aggression and lowered DA.
I know in my dogs cases, that when encouraged to follow how they were 'hard wired', the more content they are and the less likely they are to be interested in looking for another outlet.
And then I don't have the to 'hammer' into my dogs that they must behave to what I THINK is acceptable. They are dogs that have been molded by man, funny how man then changes the rules on them after hundreds of years of selective breeding........and then we label them, suppress them and expect THEM to change overnight.
So true. I was browsing an ESS forum (uk based) last night because I was bored and I came across a post that talked about how it drove them crazy that their dog sniffed on walks, so their trainer advised them to jerk the dog's head up and say "leave it!" every time it went to sniff. They said "It took a while for her to get the hang of it but she doesn't walk along sniffing anymore". I find this sad because its taking away a dog's nature. Could you imagine doing this to a hound dog? (I hear a hound dog owner laughing someplace...)
 

HoundedByHounds

Oh, it's *you*
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
8,415
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
N Texas, USA
Good behavior gets less frustration for all people and animals involved
So instead of suppressing those drives, find a way to let them free, happier and more content dogs = non aggression and lowered DA.
I know in my dogs cases, that when encouraged to follow how they were 'hard wired', the more content they are and the less likely they are to be interested in looking for another outlet.
Sounds like you two are saying the same thing...esp considering the drives both your breeds have. The needs of the dog must be met. If your dog needs structure and to be manages closely to feel secure then he is happy...if her dog needs freedom to indulge in sport or trials that assuage that instinct...her dog is happy.

We needn't control what others do with their dogs to match our own idea of what makes a dog happy, IMO. I happen to think that a Lab would be as happy in the field as being in a home adored by it's people...you chose one over the other and your dog is happy...I do NOT think the same of a JRT simply because being content with affection is NOT an integral part of their genetic makeup. They need more...this is why they need a different owner than a Lab...field bred or otherwise.

BTW jess that's me laughin ;)
 

smkie

pointer/labrador/terrier
Joined
Dec 16, 2004
Messages
55,184
Likes
35
Points
48
MY dogs are not allowed to sniff when we walk. WHen we walk they are to have walking manners. DO i let them sniff in their yard..you betcha. SNiff away at VIctor's valley or in the woods or at the dog park. SNiffing when you walk your dog means that they are leading the way with their nose and not their brain. They can smell just as good with their heads up as their heads down. From what i understand if you took the sensors out of a dogs nose and put it side by side it would cover the entire dog. WHen you walk your dog its' focus should be walking beside you in a heel position with a loose leash, not in exhibiting yard behavior. THat is any heel off leash or on. FRee time is freetime and that is not walk time.

I believe all dogs need a challanging outlet. I do not ever think that a yard and a house is enough space for a canine, mentally or physically. SO walks, agility, tricks, they should always be learning something new. Mary still surprises me in what she has interest in and wants to do. If Victor and Pepper give it a go so will she. Obedience must be learned at the same time tho. AS my old boss said, make sure they are having 50 percent of the fun...and always leave them wanting more. but the most important one..the one he told me was most important, NEVER give a command you don't enforce.
 

Sweet72947

Squishy face
Joined
May 18, 2006
Messages
9,159
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Northern Virginia
But...I walk for their pleasure. That means sniffing and exploring (while not pulling me, and listening to any commands I may give.) Daisy is part hound, I don't think it would be possible to teach her not to sniff anyways. (Hounds were bred to sniff and track, after all.)
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top