No, I think you need to consult a professional that can tell you what would be appropriate to give her. Buddy's case was extreme and he already had a compromised immune system to begin with, so the measures to help him were above and beyond. He was on colostrum, zinc, msm, vit a, vit c,vit e, astragulus root, milk thistle.. i could go on and on. Many of those may not be necessary for Carlie.
I really recommend talking to Mordy.
Yes, I realize that, which is why I think you should continue to use it.
Good luck!