Dry vs. Canned Food

J

john doe iii

Guest
#1
I'm currently feeding my 11 week old puppy Iams puppy (dry) food ... Im wondering if there are any benefits with canned vs. dry puppy food?

I received a complimentary pouch of Iams puppy food (wet) and tried it out with the puppy.... needless to say she loved it! I'm not sure if i should switch or not? Some people say giving wet version is like fast food vs. home cooking???
 

Dizzy

Sit! Good dog.
Joined
Sep 14, 2005
Messages
17,761
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Wales
#2
I feed dry food... I think just go with what you prefer. Dry food is less messy, and easier to use in my opinion. I also feed some scraps and other foods - I make sure she doesn't get extra, just different. If that makes sense. Make sure you look out for a quality food, which your dog is happy with, and you are happy with :)
 
Joined
Jul 30, 2005
Messages
1,586
Likes
0
Points
0
#3
Well first i would change to a different food, and as long as you are buying a good meat then either is ok, but for a balanced diet some dry foods need to have meat added, and dry is better fed moistened
 
Joined
Jul 30, 2005
Messages
1,586
Likes
0
Points
0
#5
tintinabulation said:
well, I feed Coco half dry food (eukanuba), and half wet food (mighty dog) and he really likes it that way
Hi JMO but those are both poor foods, a switch would be great for your dog, Eukanuba is expensive for what it is
 
Joined
Dec 25, 2005
Messages
126
Likes
0
Points
0
#6
the money for the food isn't really a problem. when I bought Coco, the store gave us samples of Eukanuba dry food, and two types of wet food: Mighty Dog and Caesar. personally, I didn't like the looks of Caesar, and Coco also wasn't as excited about it. what dry food would you recommend?
 
Joined
Jul 30, 2005
Messages
1,586
Likes
0
Points
0
#7
well it depends on whjat is available to you? i dont knoiw where you are, but its the ingredents you need to look at, both contain animal by-products which is bad
 

Sheba

I W A L R
Joined
Apr 10, 2004
Messages
4,310
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
In a wolf pack
#9
Please, do me a favor and stop encouraging (sp?) iams by buying their products. Do you know what they do to innocent dogs and cats? Ask another member on here to get you a link about it, I dont know where to get one.
 
Joined
Jul 30, 2005
Messages
1,586
Likes
0
Points
0
#11
Sheba said:
Please, do me a favor and stop encouraging (sp?) iams by buying their products. Do you know what they do to innocent dogs and cats? Ask another member on here to get you a link about it, I dont know where to get one.
Not everyone knows about the way iams treat animals, so she may not be doing it on purpose!
 

bubbatd

Moderator
Joined
Nov 28, 2004
Messages
64,812
Likes
1
Points
0
Age
91
#12
Post this in foods for Mordy to answer ... Personally I like dry, well moisted with left over veggies , meat added.
 

Rhino

New Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2005
Messages
65
Likes
0
Points
0
#13
but for a balanced diet some dry foods need to have meat added
Keep in mind that feeding ANY meat products, cooked or not, with a high grain food (like MOST commercial kibbles) can cause digestive upset and poor nutritional absorption.

Grain products digest at a MUCH slower rate then meat products, AND they raise the pH levels of the digestive tract. Dogs need an acidic digestive tract to break down and process whole fresh meat products (to make any nutritional benefit worth your while). If the dog is used to digesting a grain based meal, "supplementing" with meat will be pointless. Grains are really not a very good thing for your dog, so when a commercial food is comprised and AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) approves it, the food is genetically modified to be digestible and bio-available to the dogs digestive tract and to meet all nutritional needs.

You have two choices when feeding dogs - naturally, or processed. Mixing those, in my opinion, is a pointless exercise. Either cook your meals (which is still WAY better then a commercial diet), feed raw, or stick to an AAFCO approved diet and save yourself the hassle of "supplementing".

If you do it occasionally for the dog's taste buds, fine, but don't be lulled into thinking that meat is a "necessary" supplement to commercial diets. If the food is approved by AAFCO, then it's not nutritionally needed.

AAFCO feeding trials are PROVEN to supply a complete meal for your dog that will meet all of its nutritional needs. The thing you have to realize is that the diet is approved as "complete" through the combination of ingredients, not with or without certain "supplements" that we humans feel the need to give. Most of these diets, while complete, are still not considered a prime choice for most pets, and in my opinion, Iams is one of them. However, adding meat and veggies does not raise the quality of the meal. If anything, it will only make it that much more confusing for the body when it comes to digesting the food and absorbing the nutrients.

My family has over 60 years of combined dog experience, having bred, raised and trained field labs for most of that time. We have fed a combination of wet and dry over the years, with neither proving to be more beneficial then the other. Some people will argue that dry food provides better tooth care, but I have to argue that maintaining healthy gums and teeth is A LOT more involved then simply pouring some crunchies in a bowl. The act of chewing and gnawing on bones is very good for their teeth and gums, as are many of the other methods - brushing, manual cleaning, massaging, and not to mention many of the novelty dental products on the market today.

The most important thing to keep in mind is that the ingredients in the soft food are JUST as important as that of the dry food. I laugh when I see people feeding a holistic food, but then add Old Roy canned food. :rolleyes:

As for my dislike for Iams, as a general rule I tend to stay away from foods with animal by-products (be it chicken, turkey, beef or lamb), as well as multiple grains and/or grain by-products. Remember that corn, for example, is not a "bad" thing, per se, it's the by-products that ARE bad. Whole corn is FAR more digestible then something like corn mindlings, or corn meals.

Staying away from ANY by-products is a good thing, as it ensures the ingredients are whole and fresh, which are much easier on your dogs digestive tract.

Also stay away from chemical preservatives - like BHA/BHT and ethoxyquin. These are just a few of the basic "no-no's"... other then that, if it's not broke, then don't fix it.

Everyone has their opinions on what makes a good dog food, but I have to tell you, I've seen many dogs THRIVE on Eukanuba while others continue to suffer on premium holistic foods. It's not a food I would pick, but if someones dog does well on it, then who am I to judge?
 
Joined
Jul 30, 2005
Messages
1,586
Likes
0
Points
0
#14
yes that is why i buy a meat that is just that meat, it really depends on where you live, here in the uk all dry foods have a high grain content
 

Bear

The pomeranian
Joined
Jan 1, 2006
Messages
12
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
18
Location
Boston
#15
I could eat dry food for the rest of my life and it would never make a difference to me. I just want to make sure that my owners make a decision and stick with it or they wont be happy with the diahhrea I am going to have.

I notice a few other things.

1. When they give me treats like, vewy chewy edible bones that I digest, its the same as eating to me, and it makes me want to poop.

2. When they give me a little bit of peanut butter, like, in a kong.. it makes me really want to poop.

Food in my bowl is not the only way I have to poop, but generally I love my food. Unless I stopped eating it, I would expect my owners to keep the regularity!
 
J

Jason

Guest
#16
Bear said:
I could eat dry food for the rest of my life and it would never make a difference to me. I just want to make sure that my owners make a decision and stick with it or they wont be happy with the diahhrea I am going to have.

I notice a few other things.

1. When they give me treats like, vewy chewy edible bones that I digest, its the same as eating to me, and it makes me want to poop.

2. When they give me a little bit of peanut butter, like, in a kong.. it makes me really want to poop.

Food in my bowl is not the only way I have to poop, but generally I love my food. Unless I stopped eating it, I would expect my owners to keep the regularity!
I wish I could teach MY puppy to type. :D
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top