byb's
I consider all of the above byb's, as I don't see you mention health testing anywhere.
While I do buy, (when I buy) my dogs from breeders who title, it's not the end all for me. I would have no problem buying a dog from someone who had not titled the parents IF it was something I was really interested in.
I don't know which of my lists would be shorter, what I consider a BYB or what I don't consider a BYB LOL..
Let's put it this way, if the person pumping out puppies did not health test their breeding stock, at the "very least"..I wouldn't touch them with a ten foot pole.
Would I buy from a pet store? Well I did many many years ago, my first "adult" dog, was 25$, a gsd/collie cross, that was being sold with it's littermates at a local petstore , it was a local "oops" litter. Now? no, altho I feel bad for petstore puppies, I would never buy one. I'd rescue one, but I wouldn't buy one out of a petstore.
Diane