Ok, I should be awesome at housebreaking puppies but Lily is wierd. She can hang out with me for hours and not have to go outside. She can sleep in the bed with us from 1 am until 7 am get up go outside and then come back and sleep on the bed until 11. Well I'm trying to let her have free time in the kitchen and I'll take her out and come back five minutes later and she'll have peed or poop on the floor. I don't know if it's because I'm not there or what. It seems like we'll take her outside and then if we crate her or leave her in the kitchen she'll go. I moved the divider in her crate so it was a little smaller but she still went. So she got a bath, blowdried, and her nails painted (she's going purple this week). Does anyone have any suggestions on how to get her to hold it for a little longer. I tried to let her out for ten minutes and then crate for twenty but she can't even make it ten minutes (even after I had taken her out). Every puppy I have was different so now I am just completely at a loss. I thought I had this housebreaking thing figured out.