Calling all you Fish smart people....

xpaeanx

Active Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2008
Messages
8,387
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Long Island, NY
#22
I have the brandy snifter one... I use it as a candy jar on my desk at work. I would have bought both of them... but I have so much stuff on my desk that it wouldn't fit! LOL.
 
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
4,107
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
California
#23
Ditto.
I alreay found me a fish "tank" at Petsmart, its in the shape on a martini glass. LOL.
And all I want is a little Betta fish.
Bowls (Which is what the martini glass is) are not adequate for any fish. I know some people will disagree and say they are fine for bettas, but IMO they are not. I consider it equivalent to a human living in a closet their entire life. I prefer atleast 5 gallons for bettas (Though mine are in 10 gallons each).
 

Romy

Taxiderpy
Joined
Dec 2, 2006
Messages
10,233
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Olympia, WA
#26
Do not, I repeat, do NOT get a glo-fish.

These are chemically dyed fish. They inject them with dye to make them those pretty colors (also called Juicing). They won't live for very long, as the chemicals will eventually kill them.

Here's a great article on Death by Dyeing.

http://freshaquarium.about.com/cs/beginnerinfo/a/paintedfish.htm
GLO fish are not dyed. They are genetically engineered. Here is the website of the creators. The profits from their sales go to fund more research.

http://www.glofish.com/

Honestly I have considered getting a few, but I can't bring myself to spend $7.00 on a single danio. :p One of my friends has three that she keeps with her normal danios, they are going on 2 and a half years old now and have been just as hardy as the natural ones.
 
A

Angel Chicken

Guest
#27
Dyed, genetically engineered, whatever. Still wrong in my book. They had to inbreed somewhere along those lines which can produce "bad" fish with genetic disorders.

For those who are wondering, this is what a REAL danio is supposed to look like.



People that do that to an animal, an animal that can't defend itself nonetheless, are sorry. People who buy them are just as bad as people who buy pet shop puppies.
 

Dakotah

Kotah BEAR
Joined
Jan 1, 2008
Messages
7,998
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
GA
#28
Bowls (Which is what the martini glass is) are not adequate for any fish. I know some people will disagree and say they are fine for bettas, but IMO they are not. I consider it equivalent to a human living in a closet their entire life. I prefer atleast 5 gallons for bettas (Though mine are in 10 gallons each).
Thanks for the info. :)
 

xpaeanx

Active Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2008
Messages
8,387
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Long Island, NY
#29
Dyed, genetically engineered, whatever. Still wrong in my book. They had to inbreed somewhere along those lines which can produce "bad" fish with genetic disorders.

People that do that to an animal, an animal that can't defend itself nonetheless, are sorry. People who buy them are just as bad as people who buy pet shop puppies.
while I don't agree with genetically engineering fish, they did not "inbreed" to produce the colors. They added genes for colors. They took them out of jelly fish I believe and added them to the danios. The fish are bred normally, they just happen to have an extra gene that is not in a normal danio.
 

Laurelin

I'm All Ears
Joined
Nov 2, 2006
Messages
30,963
Likes
3
Points
0
Age
37
Location
Oklahoma
#32
We had lots of fish over the years- platies, neon tetra (we gave up on them though because they just never lasted long), goldfish, plecostomus (sp?), betta, etc.

My favorites we ever kept were guppies, though. The betta are probably the easiest.
 
A

Angel Chicken

Guest
#33
I'd recommend bettas for any new fish keeper. They are a great starter fish, they are easy to care for, and most of all, they are BEAUTIFUL!
 

Mayasmydobe

I'm PAWMAZING!
Joined
Jan 27, 2007
Messages
3,291
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
39
Location
Iowa
#34
WOW.... TONS of info to read through... lol...

I absolutly do NOT want a betta... I have had betta's before I want something different.
I looked at guppy's today and I think (well, am pretty sure) I want a few guppies... but only males. I dont want to breed at all.... (will there be a problem getting ONLY males?)

AC- I personally feel that your comment on people who "create" and buy glofish to be a little mean. Glofish were originally created to detect pollutants in the water. this is an excerpt from the glofish website with some information on the ethical concerns of the fish
Humane Treatment of Fish. We are committed to humane breeding practices, and the distributors of GloFish® fluorescent fish will make every effort to provide an exemplary, healthy environment for our fish throughout their life cycle. We encourage our customers to remember that, while unique, beautiful, and interesting, these fish are living creatures and not toys, and should be treated with the utmost care. For more information about the proper care for these fish, please visit the GloFish® Care section of our website.

Advancing Scientific Research. We value the potential of the technology that brought us fluorescent fish, and we will work to support additional medical and scientific applications that utilize this technology. GloFish® fluorescent fish were originally developed to detect pollutants in our water, one of many discoveries with roots in the ongoing biotechnology revolution. This revolution promises to aid in the fight against countless diseases and significantly improve peoples' lives and environments. We will work to promote and support this research; a portion of the proceeds from the sale of every GloFish® fluorescent fish will go towards this effort.
I dont have time to really read through all of the info everyone has to share...I will sit down later tonight and re-read it and take some notes. Thanks for all of the replies guys! you're great!
 

Romy

Taxiderpy
Joined
Dec 2, 2006
Messages
10,233
Likes
1
Points
38
Location
Olympia, WA
#35
I looked at guppy's today and I think (well, am pretty sure) I want a few guppies... but only males. I dont want to breed at all.... (will there be a problem getting ONLY males?)
With livebearers like guppies, platys, swordtails, etc. it is actually easier to get only males. They are "aggressive" breeders. They aren't mean or anything, just..persistent. Once you start adding females you generally need at least one, preferably two females per male so that the females don't get constantly harassed and stressed by all the boys chasing her around.
 

FoxyWench

Salty Sea Dog
Joined
Feb 14, 2006
Messages
7,308
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Connecticut
#36
ok #1: unlike "blueberry" and "strawberry" tetra, Glofish are not dyed, they are indeed bred in those insnae colors, they are genetically engeneered for it...personally we call them frankenfish and i feel they charge way too much for them, but unlike injected dyes these fish dont suffer and the color doesnt wash out after a couple months. NEVER buy dyed fish, dying fish is cruel and makes for weak fish...glofish however are freeky zebra danios and if you get them from a good source, actually hardy fish (zebras will survive a cycling tank!)

that being said:
general rule of thumb for TROPICAL fish is 1 gallon of water per inch of fish AT ADULT SIZE! so if your fish is going to grow to 3 inches, he needs 3 gallons at least, preferably from day 1...
this rule does not work for very large or long or very active fish, a 10 inch gouramie is NOT going to be happy in a 10 gallon tank, for those guys i like to do LENGHT (or height for angles) of at least tripple the fishes full grown lenght (so a 10 inch gouramie would need at least a 30 inch long tank, thats a 40 gallon breeder tank right there!)

it is OK to LIGHTLY overstock a tank if you are willing to do weekly waterchanges and have EXCELENT filtration (ie my cichlid tank is overstocked by about 1 fish (it helps curb agression) but i also run double filtration and do weekly water changes and cleaning!
eclips are good little tanks and the filtration is good enough that some mild overstocking is not going to do too muhc harm with the right fish...but your still going to be limited in 6 gallons.
a 10 gallon is a good size for a SMALL community tank, and a 29gallon is actually one of the best sizes to start out in (the bigger the tank the more "diluted" problems will be meaning it will take a larger fluctuation to mess up your tank than it would in a tiny tank...(hope that makes sense)

kissing goramie are not suitable for a 6 gallon, kissers can grow on average 8-10 inches.
gouramie in general do not mix well togehter in smaller tanks, a pair of dwarf gouramie need at least 10 gallons each...gourmai are labyrinth fish and related to Betta, they tend to be very teritorial (they will often fight with betta fish too!)
the "kissing" kissing gourami do is their way of fighting, males (and females) will lock lips in battle!people think aww its so cute there kidding, when in reality its all out war...!

the red tailed shark, also comonly red finned and rainbow, are not suited to most aquariums, they will easily break 4-6 inches and while fairly docile as youngsters once maturity kicks in you will find he will become the tank terror, i suggest nothing smaller than 29 gallons for a single redtailed and even that is pushing your luck. they are also not algea consumers like often adversited they are scavengers...

the Corydora, which comes in many cute color combinations of stipes spolids and spots in black white and green is a much better scavenger for any tank, but MUST be kept in groups of 5 or more! there incredibly social! these guys do an excelent job of cleaning up the dropped food but they WONT usually eat most of the algeas found int he aquarium

for "sucker fish" your refering to algea consuming "sucker mouth fish" the fish that would fall into this catergory are usually avid algea eaters (or at least start out that way)
most people imediatly think of the pleco...do NOT and i will repeat do NOT get a common pleco, they will BUST TANKS at 12+ inches full grown! they are all too often bought as babies for tiny tanks and die early for it.
there are smaller species like the bristlenose that grow in the 4-6" range, but these guys are usually much harder to find. Pleco of any kind ONLY consume alge when young, as they mature they prefer a diet of srimp flakes.
another popular one is the chinese algea eater. this is another one that is often sold to unknowing first time fish keepers, the CAE is generally a terrible fish for beginners, they are known to be hyperactive, agressive as adults and will even latch onto many fish! they too can grow LARGE (these guys are better suited for a semi agressive tank)

some better coices.
the Siamese algea eater, it will grow to about the same size as its chinese cousin but their agressivness is much lower

MY favorite especially for small tanks though is the OTTO, these small indescript colony loving algea eaters will eat the widest array of alge types (they will eat the stuff other alge eaters wont!) and they work CONSTANTLY, if your ottos not on the move or chowing on alge theres something wrong wiht him lol. these guys also have a much lower waste output than other fish, because of this they make a good addition to an already fuller tank in need of a clean up crew, but get 3 or more if you want them to be realy happy and healthy!

my FIIRST suggestion to you would be look into getting a larger tank, a 10 gallon full tropical set up all glass brand wil cost you about the same as a fancy 6 gallon eclips, ive seen the 10 gallon all lass, with light filter heater water conditioner, net, sample food all for about $60! and the foot print of a 10 gallon tan is not much bigger than the 6 in terms of its actuall foot print!
a 20 gallon long or 29 gallon will cost you a little more but open your options up amazingly!
the bigger the tank the more options!

ill give you some thoughts on what i would do...using the fish you like or alterinitive that would work, ill only list COMMON fsh that you could find at most petstores as im sure your not going to want to go searching and spending a fortune on ardr to find species your first time around
remember LIGHTLY overstocking your tank is OK as long as its LIGHT and your willing to do the waterchanges to keep the tank healthy...
for the 6 gallon

1 DWARF grouami (they come in some stunning colors have the personality of the bigger gourami but grow 2inches, they would do best in 10 gals but can be ok in 6) (2")
5 glo-fish (1.5-2" each)
3 otto cats (1" waste output per fish)


yes this tank would be overstocked, most zebras will grow 1-1.5" but some can reach 3" so you will have to keep an eye on them...but with upkeep this tank could work well.
put in some wide leafed plants like amazon sword and some caves to create some territory for the goruami.

for a 10 gallon the set up id stay with the same but it would be a much nicer sized tank for them

for 20 gallon
1 dwarf (2") or 1 blue spot (6") or 1 opaline (4")
5 glo-fish (2") or Cherry barb (one of the most peacfull of the barb 2") or Glowlight tetra (2") or black neon tetra (2") or pristella tetra (2")
3 otto
5 corydora

for a 29 gal:
as above but pick 2 groups of the 5's

good luck and have fun fish keeping is an awesome hobby but addictive.
we had lots of fish when i was a kid...but it wasnt untill i entered my mid teens i realy got into the hobby for myself (and i think that was more that i had to wait till i had my own money)
from there it grew, i started with a single better, next came another betta and a 10 gallon, then came another betta and a 29 gallon, then another 10 gallon, then a second 29 gallon and another betta and most reacently a 55 gallon.
right now i have set up
55 gal peacock
29 gal community with 1 blue gourami, a retailed rescue, and some black neon tetra
3 5 gallon betta tanks

plans to reset up
2nd 29 gallon, not sure what as yet...mabe a couple goldfish...
10 gallon shell dweller tank or dwarf puffer tank
7 gallon not sure yet...


edit to add: cuase you want guppies...

i wouldnt add guppies if you want grouami unless your doing the 20-29 gallon tank...they share too much of the same space and their bright colars can end up in agression.

with guppies you certainly CAN do all males (and its suggested because guppies breed like bunnies!) if you mix males and females its 1 male to 2-3females and expect LOTS of babies!

if your planing on doing guppies they count as 2" per fish and id skip the glofish/danios and cherry barbs, danios are notoriously fast and tend to be fin nippers who will disturb your guppies.

however, seeing you like the guppies...
heres some other suggestions

6 gallon
3-6 male guppies (lots of plants to give each boy his own territory) add some ottos or corydora and it would be a very pretty tank.

10 gallon
same as above, or add an extra filter (20 gallon filter on a 10 gallon tank or 2 10gal filters) and add some glowlight, or blackneon tetra (regular neon tetra are stunning but overbreeding has made them extreemly delicate fish, black neons ar emuch hardier!)

20 gallon
same as 20 gal above but with guppies instead of gourami and no barbs or glofish/danios

29 gallone, same suggestions as above, exchange gourami for a group of guppy and no glo-fish or barbs.
 
A

Angel Chicken

Guest
#37
Maya-- sure, it's mean, but I have seen what people can do to fish just for looks. It pisses me off, and it's cruel. Call me mean, I don't care... genetically altering ANYTHING is wrong... there are other ways to detect pollutants other than genetically altering an animal that can't even flop it's way out of a paper bag.

Just my opinion, as always.

I still think a betta is your best bet, though.
 

Mayasmydobe

I'm PAWMAZING!
Joined
Jan 27, 2007
Messages
3,291
Likes
0
Points
0
Age
39
Location
Iowa
#38
Holey schmoleys Foxy... I think you have won the award for Longest (and very informative) post in this thread! :)

I do want glofish...
but at the same time I want male guppies... we'll see..

I am trying to talk my mom into a bigger tank, like a 29 gallon with a stand... have a great area for it, but would want to put in an electrical outlet as there isnt one near (my dad owns a construction company and I have an electrician for a cousin, so this wouldnt be a HUGE undertaking) I will look around and tanks and see what I can find for my christmas budget...

Also... I really like the look of sand as the bottum.... is that something that can be done with a freshwater tank or can you only do that with live rock, and saltwater tanks?
I saw a sand substrate that had the "good" bacteria and stuff all in it...
 
A

Angel Chicken

Guest
#39
Sand can be used... it's actually safer for some fish that pick at the ground for food.

I don't recommend the pebbles. I think I'm the only person on this planet that had a fish swallow a rock and die from choking.
 

FoxyWench

Salty Sea Dog
Joined
Feb 14, 2006
Messages
7,308
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Connecticut
#40
AC ive heard of fish choking on the gravel/pebbles from a few people, its one of the reasons i prefer sand, and if im using pebbles i make sure to use something much larger than the largest fish in the tank could swallow lol

in terms of sand, the only time sand CANT be used is if your using an undergravel filter (it clogs up the filtration) in all other tanks sand is actually a better medium, many fish have natural digging behaviour, especially catfish species.

just be sure not to use cichlid sand or crushed coral (anything with added lime) as it will hike up your alkalinity too high (most tropical fish need a mildly acidic to neutral ph, cichlids need more alkalinity)

the absolute BEST type of sand, belive it or not...for fish tanks...
PLAYSAND! yup, ignore that realy expensive "fish tank sand" you can get at the petshop and head to your local home supply store, kids playsand usually comes in white and natural and now crayola makes various colored kids playsand, yup the stuff for kids sandboxes (i got mine for 1.99 for 25lbs at wallymart)

wash EXTREEMLY well (this goes for any sand, play or prepackages fish tank sand) and then add to the tank...when you first set up your tank, add sand first (i like to go thin on sand because it can compact causing bacterial pockets), then add the water, DO NOT turn your filtration on yet, give the sand a few days to settle, it WILL settle but it may take time (mine took about 5 days to completly settle)
once its settled the filters can get turned on as normal.

when you CLEAN your tank (this should be done with any substrate but especially with sand) turn off your filters and stir the sand...it doesnt have to be insane make sure every inch is done, but you want to ust give it a mix, this will break up any bad bacterial pockets, if youve got fish that dig they will help lol!
again let it settle (once its settled the first time it usually settles much faster after that mine now takes abotu 1 hour to completly settle at cleaning) and turn the filters back on...(i do mine once a month because i have cichlids and they dig!)

i wouldnt worry about the "good bacteria" too much in the substrate, most of it is just hype so youll pay more, in reality theres realy not enough to start your cycle...

id also suggest reading up on a FISHLESS cycle...it means you wont have any fish in your tank for a while...but the cycle will go quicker and your tank will be stabler in the long run doing a fishless cycle.
cycling with fish generally takes twice the time and alot of fishy lives.

honestly it realy will depend on your preference as to guppies or glofish. if you go with glowfish though and REALY want then to look spectacular, you could set up a blacklight over/neer the tank for parties...they glow REALY bright under blacklight (black, cardinal, glowlight and normal neon tetras Also look spectacular under blacklight)
and if your realy want the gourami, you could start with your goruami and glofish and then...when the addiction leeds you to want to add a tank to every room of your home, you could get a 10 gallon once you have your first tank set up and do a guppy tank...

my nightlight when i was a real lil kid was a 10 gallon tank with glowlight and neon tetra, it was set on a timer so the ligth came on at night and the fish were just on a backwards day/night cycle lol, i also had a blacklight bar just behind the tank so that when i turned that on and the main light off all the fish glowed like crazy!
It was THE best night light EVER!

One of my betta is in my bathroom on a reverse cycle (light ON at night off during the day) so that if i need to get up and use the bathroom at night i dont have to worry about turning the main light on and blinding myself and Grumpy Pants McGee the Betta. yup, fish tanks in every room lol
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top