For Tokie, she finds her own toys....mainly sticks, some very large. And no, I don't worry about splinters or choking. She chews on them and spits the little pieces out. But mostly she likes to play fetch and keep away with me. They're free and in abundance around here. And she likes tennis balls... snow balls when the snow comes thrown from the Chuckit also is a big hit. Tennis balls, she usually finds around the property from when my niece use to come here all the time and bring her tennis ball obsessed dog. So, I've never had to buy a tennis ball. Or she'll find them other places out in the woods where other dogs may have been.
All the dogs like Nyla bones. Those are expensive. Stuffies just don't work around here. All three dogs are powerful chewers and just rip them to shreds in seconds.
I like the empty peanut butter jar idea.