#1




Statistics Question  Any Math Geeks?
This has been stumping me for a bit now and I'm struggling to find the answer by googling. I am trying to compare two percentages to determine if they are statisticall different. The issue is that one of the groups is a subgroup of the second group.
I'm going to change the information around a little bit to keep confidential things confidential, but here's an equivalent setup: Let's say that I have 100 student athletes out of a population of 1000 students. 70% of the athletes like to eat at Chipotle. 55% of the entire student body likes to eat at Chipotle. I have no information specific to "nonstudent athletes" (unless it could be computed mathematically?) How to I determine if the percent of student athletes who like Chipotle is statistically different from the percent of the entire student body that likes Chiptole? Chi squared tests seem to be the answer for those situations in which you have two exclusive groups (e.g. men vs. women). But can I use the same test for the groupsubgroup analysis? And if so, how do I do it? Thank you kindly! 
#2




I love stats when I was in school but don't remember specifics. That said, are you trying to compare the whole population to the athlete population or the nonathlete population to the athlete population?
__________________
Jade: DMH Cat Tango: LH Tripod Chihuahua Practice what you preach or keep your mouth shut. 
#3




Well if I had the data for the nonathlete population, I could do athletes vs. nonathletes and then all would be good and well because each group would be exclusive of the other. Actually, that would be my ideal. But the only information that I have is athletes vs the entire student body. I don't mind doing this comparison, but I don't know how.
Unfortunately, I am not the original source of the data and it might be a pain to get the exact numbers that I would like. I already had to ask for 'n' values for each population and that took several days to come through. If I can work with what I have, that would be best. 
#4




Well, Student Athletes at 70% of 100 is 70 Chipotle Enjoyers (CE)
Total Students at 55% of 1000 is 550 CE's Since we know that Student Athletes are Students, you know that of those 550, 70 are Athletes. So Student nonathletes that are CE's would be 550  70 or 480. 1000 Students total and 100 are athletes, so the other 900 students are nonathletes. 480/900 is 53.3% of Student nonathletes are CE's.
__________________
When things don't go your way, stop and think, "Problem, or inconvenience?"  with apologies to Robert Fulghum 
#5




Firstly, thank you! I appreciate that  that's all I needed
Secondly, I am embarrassed at the extent to which my math skills have gone down the tube. Four years ago I would have laughed at my current state! So anyhow, thank you! 
Bookmarks 
Thread Tools  
Display Modes  

