In my case, I didn't actually become a breeder on purpose. It wasn't something I'd ever aspired to, in fact, I had a bit of a dread of it. But I had this nice bitch:
When her breeder gave her to me, she said I could try showing if I wanted, and I thought it might be fun, so I didn't spay my Tully. Tully never did crap in the AKC ring, didn't like showing, and eventually I gave up (this photo was taken at a UKC event, she did finish her UKC CH title... at this event, actually) She was a little challenging for me to work with in obedience and agility at first. But around 3 years old, she suddenly grew up, and became a really impressive partner. People at obedience trials were telling me they wanted one like her.
I also had been looking around while I was trying to show her, and reading what people said on breed lists, and what I was seeing was that while the cosmetic defects that my bitch had were precluding her from winning in the AKC breed ring, her really good, sound structure was something that wasn't that common. Especially her solid, well angulated front. I had figured there'd be no point to breeding her, since she wasn't anything that special, but the more I looked around, the more I thought she was more special than I'd originally thought.
So, I mentioned to her breeder that I might like to breed her, and that people had been asking. We'd never talked about it, and I kind of assumed she wouldn't want me to, but she said she had no problem with it, and suggested a stud. Which was the one problem I'd had... thinking of the perfect stud. Since I wasn't really sure my bitch was breed-worthy, I decided I would
only breed her if I could find a health-tested stud, also with good structure, performance titled, and with cosmetic virtue to remedy her faults. Also, an outcross (my bitch was more tightly bred than I was comfortable with), but with good reason to think it would work with her lines.
I had kind of figured that setting up that criteria meant that I would never have to actually follow through on the plan, but the breeder immediately suggested an Australian GR CH with a CDX, who had produced a really nice litter when bred to my bitch's dam. Basically, the exact dog I had figured I wouldn't find. She later came up with another dog possibility, so I could have a choice, but that first suggestion was too perfect.
So, I left it to fate. Did a surgical AI, and figured whatever happened, was what was meant to be. What did happen was a really terrible whelping experience leaving me with one pup, my Tess, who I of course kept. Then I had to disappoint the people I had waiting.
Was it worth it? I don't know. I got an amazing dog. I also spent a whole lot of money, I could have bought a dog for less. I did produce what I wanted to produce: a beautiful, breed standard Stafford who is also an exceptional performance dog, and has sound enough structure to work without hurting herself. I'd meant to produce
more of them. My decision to breed Tess was easier, and was never really in question. She was always exceptional, and I always knew she should reproduce. I do regret spaying her after her one very small litter, but the bright side is, I have Pirate, who again, is what I aim to produce, and can hopefully pass on those strengths more easily.
I sure could have saved myself a lot of money by just buying my dogs, though.