I was a member of the shiloh club oh,,probably 15 years ago when I was looking into the breed. (i've always had gsd's).
Otch is right, their "writings" were great in theory but what was /is actually going on sucks.
The founder proclaims their mission was to breed the "old style/original GSD'.
Well if "Max" the founder ever saw gsd's of today (shilohs as well) he'd flip over in his grave because Shilohs certainly were not his idea of the "original" breed.
Anyhow, she bred bigger to bigger, long coat, I've heard their Mal thrown in for size as well, she has imported a couple GSD's to diversify blood..
In the end, I've met quite a few very very disgruntled clients of Shilohs.
Of the Shiloh's I have met, I've liked two, most have very skitzy /shy temperaments, hip /elbow probs,,(check ofa database and see how many have passed),,and other health probs..I guess what I dislike most, is the temperaments, to soft, far and few in between that could "work"..
Lovely to look at, but the whole package is missing alot. Just my opinion
(Oh there is an offshoot club of the original that IS trying to straighten out the mess , I give them credit, but they have a small gene pool to work from.
Now the KING shepherd is also an offshoot of the Shiloh's)
Diane