Returning a dog to the breeder - Questions/Rant

[yoko]

Originally Posted by Jynx

I have found this entire 'novel' to be interesting.

I do not condone nor ever would condone someone lying, neglecting, abusing, starving a puppy/dog or any animal. What the OP did was pretty disturbing and I'm so glad the puppy went back to the breeder and is now a healthy dog.

I guess what rather bothers me, is the original thread was started what? A year ago? the puppy was returned to the breeder what? A year ago?

I would think if the 'breeder' wanted the entire world to know the disturbing facts, they would have posted it themselves vs someone else taking it upon themselves to just revive a thread that was OVER a year old and resolved?

So again, I absolutely do not condone what the OP or anyone else who does this, did.

Has this Teal person (that I have no knowledge of) changed her ways? Does ANYONE know this?

What I find disturbing is, this event happened a YEAR ago, I'm sure alot of posters to this thread have done something (maybe not as disturbing) a year or more ago that no one knows about..Are the internet police going to dig into their past indiscressions and "out" them??

I'm sure the person who revived this thread and others have skeletons in their closet that they may not want the internet world to know of, and would be possibly 'burned at the stake' for as well.

I guess I would have just rather saw, the facts , the puppy was returned, do not adopt/sell to this person again vs all the nit picking, shoulda , coulda , speculation .

Again, I do not have knowledge of the OP, nor the people involved, I just think there comes a point when it's no ones business, take care of what's in your own backyard.

I know this board is full of animal lovers, as it should be, and I am as well, they have no voice, we have to be their voice, but something that was seemingly resolved over a year ago with a HAPPY ENDING, why rehash it? Put out the DNA, and be done with it.

Just my 2 cents

I'm on my cell phone so can't find right now but there was an explanation as to why the breeder didn't respond right away.

And based off the fact that she continued to lie about it after ward and disappeared when proof was show AND is looking into another puppy already I'm going to go out on a limb and say no she hasn't changed.

[JessLough]

Originally Posted by Jynx

I have found this entire 'novel' to be interesting.

I do not condone nor ever would condone someone lying, neglecting, abusing, starving a puppy/dog or any animal. What the OP did was pretty disturbing and I'm so glad the puppy went back to the breeder and is now a healthy dog.

I guess what rather bothers me, is the original thread was started what? A year ago? the puppy was returned to the breeder what? A year ago?

I would think if the 'breeder' wanted the entire world to know the disturbing facts, they would have posted it themselves vs someone else taking it upon themselves to just revive a thread that was OVER a year old and resolved?

So again, I absolutely do not condone what the OP or anyone else who does this, did.

Has this Teal person (that I have no knowledge of) changed her ways? Does ANYONE know this?

What I find disturbing is, this event happened a YEAR ago, I'm sure alot of posters to this thread have done something (maybe not as disturbing) a year or more ago that no one knows about..Are the internet police going to dig into their past indiscressions and "out" them??

I'm sure the person who revived this thread and others have skeletons in their closet that they may not want the internet world to know of, and would be possibly 'burned at the stake' for as well.

I guess I would have just rather saw, the facts , the puppy was returned, do not adopt/sell to this person again vs all the nit picking, shoulda , coulda , speculation .

Again, I do not have knowledge of the OP, nor the people involved, I just think there comes a point when it's no ones business, take care of what's in your own backyard.

I know this board is full of animal lovers, as it should be, and I am as well, they have no voice, we have to be their voice, but something that was seemingly resolved over a year ago with a HAPPY ENDING, why rehash it? Put out the DNA, and be done with it.

Just my 2 cents

Because chazzers don't want this to happen to the next dog of the hour.

If she had changed, she would ADMIT IT. No, she keeps lying, making up excuses, and challenging everybody. (or sending in her sidekicks to do it)

As for the rest of your questions, they have all already been answered.

[Danefied]

Somewhere in the thread (forgive me for not going back to look) it was said that Teal herself contacted the breeder just a few weeks ago - for what, I don’t know. Nor do I know why RC contacted the breeder. But I got the impression from the breeder that Teal contacting her again recently prompted the posting of the pictures.

[Dogdragoness]

Because as Dr. Phil says: past behavior is a good indicator of future bahavior.

[Jynx]

yoko, thanks for answering,,I guess the breeder part (I think they responded here? way back when, but a year after the incident?) I was just wondering why now? Why not come on here last year and say "this is what happened".. Maybe they responded now because they were unaware of what transpired here a year ago, that was kinda my question I guess and I guess I may have answered myself..

and no if a person has not changed in a year, maybe doubtful they will ever change, I was just wondering if anyone "KNEW"she had changed / learned from her mistakes or not.

And I just want to say having gsds my entire life, the pic of the gsd, is not a healthy looking dog He's to ribby, coat looks out of condition Hope he's had some fattening up

[Dogdragoness]

not every dog is the same. he could have been out of coat, coat can very from dog to dog in GSDs, also it can differ from show lines to working lines, which RC's GSD seems to be.

[Jynx]

uh, yeah I know a little about gsd's, I've had them for over 30 years working lines. The dog in the pic is way to ribby, I don't like fat dogs, but he needs a few pounds on him, just sayin

[Linds]

I don't really know why Red Chrome or her dogs keep being brought into question. It's irrelevant to the condition of the Fila. Once again I say that she could boil babies for fun every thursday night and it wouldn't change what Teal did to the puppy.

[Fran101]

Originally Posted by Linds

I don't really know why Red Chrome or her dogs keep being brought into question. It's irrelevant to the condition of the Fila. Once again I say that she could boil babies for fun every thursday night and it wouldn't change what Teal did to the puppy.

This.

[JessLough]

Originally Posted by Jynx

uh, yeah I know a little about gsd's, I've had them for over 30 years working lines. The dog in the pic is way to ribby, I don't like fat dogs, but he needs a few pounds on him, just sayin

You mean like his owner said, lots of pages ago?

Having a dog breed for over 30 years means nothing in a lot of cases other than you've had dog for over 30 years (Not saying YOU, I just always laugh when people are like "I'VE HAD DOGS FOR THIS MANY YEARS")